53. The following appeared as part of an editorial in a weekly newsmagazine.
Historically, most of this countrys engineers have come from our universities; recently, however, our university-age population has begun to shrink, and decreasing enrollments in our high schools clearly show that this drop in numbers will continue throughout the remainder of the decade. Consequently, our nation will soon be facing a shortage of trained engineers. If we are to remain economically competitive in the world marketplace, then, we must increase funding for education―and quickly.
Discuss how well reasoned... etc.
An editorial in a weekly news magazine warns that we must quickly increase funding for education in order to remain economically competitive in the world marketplace. The line of reasoning is that the nation will soon face a shortage of engineers because engineers have come from universities, and that our university-age population is shrinking. Moreover, decreasing enrollments in high schools clearly show that this drop in university-age students will continue throughout the decade. The authors argument is not convincing because it is based on several questionable assumptions.
First, the author assumes that because our university-age population is shrinking, university enrollments will likewise shrink. But even if the number of university-age students is dropping, it is possible that a greater proportion of those students will enter universities. If this percentage were sufficiently large, university enrollments could remain relatively stable. Moreover, even if overall university enrollments did drop, we must further assume that the number of engineering students would likewise drop. However, decreases in overall enrollments do no necessarily result in proportional enrollment decreases in each field of study. If demand for engineers were high, then a larger percentage of university students might study to become engineers, in which case engineering enrollments could increase or remain constant, while those in other major fields of study would drop disproportionately.
An additional assumption is that economic success in the world marketplace depends on the number of engineers produced by our universities. This assumption is simplistic. Professionals in other fields―such as agriculture, banking, and business―may contribute equally to our global success. The author does not explain why the predicted shortage of engineers is more critical than shortages in other fields that might result from shrinking university enrollments. Nor does the author demonstrate that providing more funds for education will correct the predicted shortage of engineers. Even if all of the previous assumptions are accepted, no connection between increased funding and the desired enrollment increase has been established.
In conclusion, the author has failed to make a convincing case for increased funding for education. Before we accept the conclusion, the author must provide evidence that we face a critical shortage of engineers, and that increased funding will have direct bearing on correcting this shortage. As it stands, both these claims rest on unwarranted assumptions.
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:生命
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:关于离婚率的上升
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:自行车与汽车争道
高中实用英语写作之资讯通讯
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:Pressure in Modern Life
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:细心与粗心
高中实用英语写作之口头通知活动安排
高中实用英语写作之致答词
高中英语作文:周末-Weekends
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:No Sweet without Sweat
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:未来的水资源问题
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:如何面对考试
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:妇女权益
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:私立学校的利弊
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:无车日的倡议
高中实用英语写作之影讯海报
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:车祸下降的城市
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:自行车在中国
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:失业给中国带来了什么?
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:没有电会怎么样?
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:My View on Money
高中英语作文:致词-Farewell Wpeech
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:论妇女的成功
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:English Reading
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:逆境是成功的关键
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:女性在现代世界
高中实用英语写作之自我介绍
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:友谊是什么?
高中英语作文:植物-Plants
英语作文辩证逻辑实例:关于交友
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |