79. The following appeared as part of a company memorandum.
Adopting an official code of ethics regarding business practices may in the long run do our company more harm than good in the public eye. When one of our competitors received unfavorable publicity for violating its own code of ethics, it got more attention from the media than it would have if it had had no such code. Rather than adopt an official code of ethics, therefore, we should instead conduct a publicity campaign that stresses the importance of protecting the environment and assisting charitable organizations.
Discuss how well reasoned... etc.
This company memorandum suggests that, in lieu of adopting an official code of ethics, the company should conduct a publicity campaign that stresses the importance of promoting certain societal interests. The reason for the suggestion is that an official code of ethics might harm the company in the public eye because a competing company received unfavorable publicity for violating its own ethics code. This argument is unconvincing, since it depends on several unwarranted assumptions as well as arguing against its own conclusion.
First of all, the author unfairly assumes that the two companies are sufficiently similar to ensure the same consequences of adopting an ethics code for this company as for its competitor. The competitor may have adopted an entirely different code from the one this company might adopt―perhaps with unrealistic standards not embraced by any other companies. Perhaps the competitors violation was extremely egregious, amounting to an aberration among businesses of its type; or perhaps one notorious executive is solely responsible for the competitors violation. Any of these scenarios, if true, would show that the two companies are dissimilar in ways relevant to the likelihood that this company will experience similar violations and similar publicity if it adopts any ethics code.
Secondly, the author unfairly assumes that the competitor was damaged by its code violation and the resulting publicity more than it would have been had it not violated its code. Just as likely, however, the violation was necessary to ensure a certain level of profitability or to protect other important interests. Without knowing the extent and nature of the damage resulting from the bad publicity or the reason for the violation, we cannot accept the authors conclusion.
Thirdly, the authors proposal is inconsistent with the authors conclusion about the consequences of adopting an ethics code. The author suggests that, instead of adopting an ethics code, this company should stress the importance of protecting the environment and assisting charitable organizations. This proposal is tantamount to adopting an ethics code. In this sense, the author suggests going against his own advice that the company should not adopt such a code.
In conclusion, differences between this company and its competitor may undermine the authors conclusion that this company should not adopt an ethics code. To better evaluate the argument, we need more information about the nature of the competitors ethics code and about the nature and extent of the violation. To strengthen the argument, the author must accord his advice with his conclusion that the company should not adopt an ethics code.
嘉能可-斯特拉塔并购可能遭股东否决
Lex专栏:中国经济放缓影响美国企业业绩
美国消费者对中国产品的需求回升
美文 父亲的眼睛
美国经济亟需解决的问题
中国汽车销售逆势高增长
患难真情-动物让我们感动
三岁看大 七岁看老
土耳其迫使叙利亚客机降落搜缴“违禁货物”
一篇真正出类拔萃的文章
中国称东盟论坛不适合谈南海问题
Five Balls Of Life
青春不是年华,而是心境
永远不会后悔-母爱的真谛
德克萨斯州一辆卡车撞毁11人丧生
奥运让伦敦市中心变“鬼城”
宽恕的艺术 Forgiveness
马来西亚洗车店洗车9次送性服务
爱情的见证
上帝创造父亲God & Father
幸福生活20法则 20 Keys to a Happy Life
人人有本难念的经
克林顿呼吁制定行为准则解决南海争端
美议员:烧掉中国产的美国奥运代表团队服
一段感人的"蓝"的生死恋
与朋友分享美丽的熏衣草
另一种爱
李明博为贪腐丑闻向全国道歉
奥林匹克运动员 Olympic Athletes
不一样的春天 Spring
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |