21. The following appeared as part of an editorial in an industry newsletter.
While trucking companies that deliver goods pay only a portion of highway maintenance costs and no property tax on the highways they use, railways spend billions per year maintaining and upgrading their facilities. The government should lower the railroad companies property taxes, since sending goods by rail is clearly a more appropriate mode of ground transportation than highway shipping. For one thing, trains consume only a third of the fuel a truck would use to carry the same load, making them a more cost-effective and environmentally sound mode of transport. Furthermore, since rail lines already exist, increases in rail traffic would not require building new lines at the expense of taxpaying citizens.
Discuss how well reasoned... etc.
The conclusion of this editorial is that the government should lower property taxes for railroad companies. The first reason given is that railroads spend billions per year maintaining and upgrading their facilities. The second reason is that shipping goods by rail is cost-effective and environmentally sound. This argument is unconvincing for several reasons.
First of all, the argument depends upon a misleading comparison between railroad and truck company expenditures. Although trucking companies do not pay property tax on roads they use, they do pay such taxes on the yards, warehouses and maintenance facilities they own. And while trucking companies pay only a portion of road maintenance costs, this is because they are not sole users of public roads. Railroad companies shoulder the entire burden of maintenance and taxes on their own facilities and tracks; but they distribute these costs to other users through usage fees.
In addition, the author assumes that property taxes should be structured to provide incentives for cost-effective and environmentally beneficial business practices. This assumption is questionable because property taxes are normally structured to reflect the value of property. Moreover, the author seems to think that cost-effectiveness and environmental soundness are equally relevant to the question of tax relief. However, these are separate considerations. The environmental soundness of a practice might be relevant in determining tax structuring, but society does not compensate a business for its cost-efficiency.
Splitting the issues of cost-efficiency and environmental impact highlights an ambiguity in the claim that railway shipping is more appropriate. On the one hand, it may be appropriate, or prudent, for me to ship furniture by rail because it is cost-effective; on the other hand, it might be appropriate, or socially correct, to encourage more railway shipping because it is environmentally sound. The argument thus trades on an equivocation between social correctness on the one hand, and personal or business prudence on the other.
In sum, this argument is a confusion of weak comparisons, mixed issues and equivocal claims. I would not accept the conclusion without first determining: the factors relevant to tax structure, whether specific tax benefits should accrue to property as well as to income and capital gains taxes, whether railway shipping really does provide greater social benefits, and whether it is correct to motivate more railway shipping on this basis.
职场美语视频:Expressing a negative opinion用英语做出否定的评价
职场美语视频:Keeping the conversation going
职场口语一学就会:上班族等词的口语表达
职场美语视频:Talking abaut future pians谈谈将来的计划
职场口语一学就会:绞尽脑汁的口语表达
职场英语情景交际之为新工作考核和拼命加班
职场口语一学就会:商量今后的事上
职场美语对话第15集:接电话培训,提高接电话技巧
职场口语一学就会:扭转等词的口语表达
职场美语视频:Moving into other topics 转到其他话题
职场口语一学就会:千载难逢的机会的口语表达
职场美语对话第19集:如何解释并消除误会
职场口语一学就会:博物馆、美术馆等方面词的口语表达
职场英语情景交际之你被解雇了
职场美语视频:Calling information:呼叫信息
职场美语视频:Introducing the topic :介绍主题
职场口语一学就会:本事技术的口语表达
职场口语一学就会:辞职的话
职场美语视频:Calling collect:(phone)对方付费电话
职场英语情景交际之被炒鱿鱼
职场美语视频:向朋友或同事介绍自己的家庭
职场英语情景交际之为另谋发展,辞职离开公司
职场美语视频:讨论去哪里旅行
职场英语情景交际之介绍新同事
职场口语一学就会:生物科技等词的口语表达
职场美语视频:Asking directions问路必备英语
职场美语视频:Disagrering不赞同同事的意见
职场口语一学就会:消费者基金会等词的口语表达
职场美语视频:请同事吃饭并不允许对方拒绝
职场口语一学就会:首创等词的口语表达
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |