58. The following appeared as part of an article on government funding of environmental regulatory agencies.
When scientists finally learn how to create large amounts of copper from other chemical elements, the regulation of copper mining will become unnecessary. For one thing, since the amount of potentially available copper will no longer be limited by the quantity of actual copper deposits, the problem of overmining will quickly be eliminated altogether. For another, manufacturers will not need to use synthetic copper substitutes, the production of which creates pollutants. Thus, since two problems will be settled―overmining and pollution―it makes good sense to reduce funding for mining regulation and either save the money or reallocate it where it is needed more.
Discuss how well reasoned... etc.
The author contends that it makes good sense to reduce funding for mining regulation, because regulatory problems with over-mining and pollution will be solved when scientists learn how to create large amounts of copper from other chemical elements. One reason the author gives for this conclusion is that the problem of over-mining will be quickly eliminated when the amount of potentially available copper is no longer limited by the quantity of actual copper deposits. Another reason given is that pollution problems created by production of synthetic copper substitutes will be eliminated when manufacturers no longer depend on substitutes. This argument is weak because the conclusion goes beyond the scope of the premises and because the argument relies on questionable assumptions.
To begin with, the wording of the conclusion suggests that funding for mining regulation generally should be reduced, yet the premises are about copper mining only. There are many mined resources other than copper; advances in copper synthesis technology will in all likelihood have no bearing on whether regulation of other kinds of mining should be changed.
Furthermore, the argument depends on the assumption that copper mining will slow down once copper can be chemically synthesized. However, the author provides no evidence to substantiate this assumption. Moreover, it is entirely possible that copper mining will remain less expensive than copper synthesis. If so, there will be no incentives, outside of regulatory ones, to slow down copper mining. In a word, the problem of over-mining will remain.
Finally, the argument relies on the assumption that synthesizing copper will not create the same kind of pollution problems as those resulting from the synthesis of copper substitutes. However, the author provides no evidence to substantiate this assumption. Without such evidence, we cannot accept the premise that pollution problems will be eliminated by switching from producing copper substitutes to producing copper itself.
In conclusion, I am not convinced on the basis of this argument that the time has come to cut funding for the regulation of mining in general, or even for the regulation of copper mining in particular. To strengthen the argument, the author must restrict the scope of the conclusion to copper mining rather than to mining in general. The author must also provide support for the two assumptions underlying the argument.
扇子的文化
国际英语资讯:Chinese students at UM receive health kits from homeland
三峡水库建成的利与弊
A Lovely Boy 一个可爱的男孩
体坛英语资讯:Uganda targets knockout stage in 2020 African Nations Championship
我要克隆塞尚
国际英语资讯:Brazils justice minister Sergio Moro resigns
为防止民众聚集 日本城镇忍痛剪光玫瑰和郁金香
我看克隆
事物的正确答案不止一个
莲莲,知为谁生
爱无限
莲之泪
父爱远去如山隔
国内英语资讯:China Focus: National public health month highlights epidemic prevention
体坛英语资讯:Relegation-threatened Augsburg sack coach Schmidt
国内英语资讯:Chinese doctors rich experience important for Uzbekistan in COVID-19 fight: official
雄伟的荆州长江大桥
未来的桥
国内英语资讯:Chinese envoy vows to continue to provide aid, urges against politicization of pandemic
假如我是桥梁设计师
故乡的冬天
他们为什么能在智力竞赛中获奖
麦当劳与永和豆浆
体坛英语资讯:Laffont, Kingsbury take FIS dual moguls win in Krasnoyarsk
端午节起源
国际英语资讯:British PM to return to work in Downing Street on Monday: reports
国际英语资讯:Palestine urges Israel to release prisoner diagnosed with COVID-19
我看克隆
盛开在人们心中的莲
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |