Hope is Healthy
You are about to go to the hospital for a routine surgical procedure. Which attitude is healthier?
A. Id better find out everything I can about this operationyou can never know too much.
B. Dont tell me the details. Its going to be fine.
Answer B is supposed to be the wrong one. Its an example of what psychologists call denial, a defence mechanism that minimizes uncomfortable information. Denial, they have argued, is stupid, self-defeating and ultimately dangerous.
But research is showing that answer B is a faster route to recovery. Denialof a certain sort and at certain timescan be healthy. Of course, you do need to pay attention to some unpleasant facts. The trick is to know when its helpful to worry and when its counterproductive.
Out-and-out denial may be the best approach to surgery, according to Richard S. Lazarus, professor of psychology at the University of California at Berkeley. With Frances Cohen, Lazarus studied 61 patients about to undergo operations . In general, patients followed one of two mental strategies; avoidance or vigilance.
Typically, avoiders had not discussed their surgery in detail with anyone, didnt want to know about it and didnt dwell upon its risks.
In contrast, vigilant types were alert to every detail. Many sought out articles about their disorders. They wanted to know the risks of surgery, the risks if surgery was not performed, the surgical procedures, the potential complications and the likelihood of recurrence.
When Lazarus and Cohen compared the two groups after surgery, they found that avoiders got on much better. They had a lower incidence of postoperative complications such as nausea , headache, fever and infection. The net result: they were discharged sooner.
One reason may be that their denial make room for hope, or at least for a positive outlook, even under the grimmest of conditions. Never deny the diagnosis, but do deny the negative opinion that may go with it, advises Norman Cousins, author of Anatomy of an Illness and The Healing Heart. Why? Because grim warnings about diseases come from statistics on the average case. Cousins believes that most patients, given hope and determination, have a good chance to transcend the averages.
Adds Dr. Hackett: Deniers see the machines theyre hooked up to as helping them to get well, not as a sign of a badly functioning heart. Those who feel most positive about their ability to get well tend to do better than those who fear and worry more.
Of course, none of these researchers would conclude that denial is the best approach to all medical matters. A diabetic must monitor blood sugar; a kidney patient must keep track of dialysis ; a woman who finds a lump in her breast must not delay in having it diagnosed.
The question to ask yourself, Dr. Lazarus explains, is whether the information you gather will help you solve a problem, or whether there is little you can do to change things. In the first case, pay attention and act. In the second case, dont become preoccupied with the risks; anxiety can worsen your health.
Dr. Herbert Benson, associate professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School, points out that the overly vigilant patients central nervous system becomes aroused into the fight-or-flight response. But since all the patient can do is lie there, his body suffers the classic damages of stress.
While studying peoples reactions to medical stress, Temple University psychologist Suzanne Miller and University of Pennsylvania gynecologic oncologist Charles E. Mangan placed 40 women about to undergo colposcopy in two different groups, according to their coping style.
Millers main interest was to see whether any of these women would cope better if they had extra information. She gave half of each group voluminous details about what would happen and how they would feel; she gave the rest only the basic facts. Overall, the results reinforced the benefits of avoidance. The women given minimal information felt more relaxed throughout the procedure than the women who knew more.
Millers research shows that different people react to news about their situations in very different ways. That means, she suggests, that people should seek as much or as little information as their individual coping style dictates.
Does the research on denial mean we should regress to the days when physicians used to say, Dont tell patients anything, because they dont really want to know? Hardly. People have a right to know what is going to happen to them, and to take part in decisions about their treatment. But patients can get necessary information without learning a lot of nerve-racking details they dont need.
For example, a physician can say: You have a suspicious Pap test. The next procedure is called colposcopy; it will take fifteen minutes. The doctor doesnt need to describe everything a colposcope does, feels like or might find. Similarly, a woman should seek all the options if she has a suspicious Pap test, but once she makes a decision, she should not be obsessed about it.
You could summarize the research in a set of guidelines:
In general, it is best to block out medical threats and worries when there is nothing you can do about themsay, after youve decided to undergo surgery. Dont dwell on all that could go wrong or visualize every fearful detail; concentrate instead on what is likely to go right.
Be vigilant about matters that you can control, such as paying attention to signs of illness.
Find out your personal disposition to avoid details or to acquire all information possible, and let your own inclination be your guidebut only up to a point. Many of those who gather any and all facts are putting themselves through more stress than they need to, Miller says. She advises them to learn when their approach will only increase their anxiety. In those cases, theyd do better to turn off their radar. On the other hand, avoiders should recognize when it is valuable to gather more facts than they might like to.
The basic advice is clear: dont feel guilty if you decide to take the rosy view. Concentrating on the positive turns out to be medically sound.
1. It is suggested in the passage that if you were a vigilant patient, you should learn to adopt a new strategy of avoidance because it brings you less stress.
2. The doctors are discovering that the best medicine is often simply to deny the worst and expect the best.
3. Miller divided the women patients into two groups at will and provided each group with either detailed or basic information in order to find out who would get on better.
4. Based on the findings of the researches, doctors find it hard to decide whether they should tell patients anything about their illness.
5. Psychologists have changed their opinion that it is stupid and dangerous for people to deny uncomfortable information.
6. A tip for both deniers and vigilant patients is: avoid details or acquire much information following your own coping style, but only to a certain point.
7. It is unnecessary for patients to get information about their disorders because there is nothing they can do about their illness.
8. Patients generally fall into two groups: _______and_______.
9. A diabetic must monitor blood sugar; helps explain that_______to all cases.
10. All patients should pay attention to_______.
I. N 2. Y 3. N 4. N 5. NG 6. Y 7. N
8. avoiders, deniers 9. denial is not the best approach 10. signs of illness
2017届高考英语一轮复习课时作业26:Unit 1《Art》(人教版选修6湖北专用)
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业23:Unit 3《Life in the future》(新人教版必修5)
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业49:语法专练九之情态动词和虚拟语气
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业11:Unit 1《Festivals around the world》(新人教版必修3)
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业45:语法专练五之介词及介词短语
2017届高三英语人教版综合能力测试六
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业4:Unit 4《Earthquakes》(新人教版必修1)
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业7:Unit 2《The Olympic Games》(新人教版必修2)
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业47:语法专练七之动词的时态和语态
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业19:Unit 4《Body language》(新人教版必修4)
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业53:语法专练十二之连词和状语从句
2017届高三英语人教版综合能力测试四
2017届高三英语人教版综合能力测试一
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业18:Unit 3《A taste of English humour》(新人教版必修4)
2017届高考英语一轮复习课时作业18:Unit 3《A taste of English humour》(人教版必修4湖北专用)
2017届高考英语阅读素材:女人的三十二个秘密
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业50:语法专练十之定语从句
2017届高三英语人教版综合能力测试三
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业51:语法专练十一之名词性从句
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业6:Unit 1《Cultural relics》(新人教版必修2)
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业5:Unit5 《Nelson Mandela—a modern hero》(新人教版必修1)
2017届高考英语一轮复习课时作业27:Unit 2《Poems》(人教版选修6湖北专用)
2017届高三英语人教版综合能力测试二
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业55:语法专练十五之交际用语
2017届高三英语人教版综合能力测试八
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业54:语法专练十四之主谓一致
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业52:语法专练十二之连词和状语从句
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业12:Unit 2《Healthy eating》(新人教版必修3)
2017届高三英语一轮复习课时作业1:Unit 1《Friendship》(新人教版必修1)
2017届高考英语一轮复习课时作业22:Unit 2《The United Kingdom》(人教版必修5湖北专用)
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |