42. The following appeared in the opinion section of a national newsmagazine.
To reverse the deterioration of the postal service, the government should raise the price of postage stamps. This solution will no doubt prove effective, since the price increase will generate larger revenues and will also reduce the volume of mail, thereby eliminating the strain on the existing system and contributing to improved morale.
Discuss how well reasoned... etc.
The author concludes that a postage-stamp price increase is needed to reduce the deterioration of the postal service. The author reasons that raising the price of stamps will accomplish this goal because it will generate more revenue, thereby eliminating the strain on the system. The author further reasons that a price increase will also reduce the volume of mail, thereby improving the morale of postal workers. The reasoning in this argument is problematic in three respects.
The main problem with the argument is the authors mistaken assumption that eliminating strain on the system and improving employee morale are mutually achievable by way of an increase in stamp prices. A price increase will generate more revenue only if the volume of mail remains constant or increases. But, if the volume of mail increases or remains constant, worker morale will not be improved. On the other hand, if the price increase reduces the volume of mail, revenues may decrease, and the strain on the system will not be eliminated. Consequently, eliminating the strain on the system and improving the morale of the workers cannot both be achieved by simply raising the price of postage stamps.
Secondly, the authors conclusion that the proposed price increase is necessary to reduce deterioration of the postal service relies on the assumption that no other action would achieve the same result. However, the author provides no evidence to substantiate this assumption. It is possible, for example, that careful cost-cutting measures that do not decrease worker morale might achieve the same goal. It is also possible that other revenue-enhancing measures that do not undermine employee morale are available.
Thirdly, the author unfairly assumes that reducing mail volume and increasing revenues will improve employee morale. This is not necessarily the case. It is possible that employee morale is materially improved only by other means, and that additional revenues will not be used in ways that improve morale. It is also possible that a decrease in mail volume will result in a reduction of the size of the labor force, regardless of revenues, which in turn might undermine morale.
In conclusion, the authors proposed solution to the problem of the deterioration of the postal service will not work. Raising postage-stamp prices cannot bring about both of the outcomes the author identifies as being necessary to solve the problem. Before we can accept the argument, the author must modify the proposal accordingly and must provide more information about the relationship between employee morale and mail volume.
如何用英语表达“原来啊…”
2011年实用口语练习:与天气有关的口语(下)
9句狠话教你怎么用英语让人“滚开”
实用口语:关于衣服的必备短语
英文结婚短信祝福语
2011年实用口语练习:各种睡不着
2011年实用口语练习:“挑刺儿”
2011年实用口语练习:有钱人 称心如意
2011年实用口语练习:出恭的各种表达
如何提高英语口语
如何用英文表达“满意”
2011年实用口语练习:不只是裸露这么简单
男生女生:我们可以只当朋友吗?
2011年实用口语练习:今日事今日毕
英语口语-商业信函用语引言
2011年实用口语练习:生活奢华的猪
2011年实用口语练习:各种哭的说法(二)
八句话表达感情纠葛
2011年实用口语练习:劝君“上当”一回
2011年实用口语练习:歉意如何说出口 1
2011年实用口语练习:课余阅读
2011年实用口语练习:同性恋的种种
2011年实用口语练习:In the bookstore 在书店里
2011年实用口语练习:说客 拾人牙慧
2011年实用口语练习:当猪飞起来的时候
2011年实用口语练习:今天我做东
2011年实用口语练习:我是无辜的
2011年实用口语练习:5=击掌?
2011年实用口语练习:英语客套话
2011年实用口语练习:“锅中的火花”
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |