68. The following appeared in a memorandum from a companys marketing department.
Since our company started manufacturing and marketing a deluxe air filter six months ago, sales of our economy filter―and company profits―have decreased significantly. The deluxe air filter sells for 50 percent more than the economy filter, but the economy filter lasts for only one month while the deluxe filter can be used for two months before it must be replaced. To increase repeat sales of our economy filter and maximize profits, we should discontinue the deluxe air filter and concentrate all our advertising efforts on the economy filter.
Discuss how well reasoned... etc.
The companys marketing department recommends discontinuing a deluxe air filter and concentrating advertising efforts on an economy filter, which requires replacement more often than the deluxe model. This recommendation is based on reports showing that sales of economy filters, and company profits, have dropped significantly since the company began manufacturing and marketing the deluxe filter six months ago. The marketing departments argument is specious in three important respects.
First, the marketing department assumes that if the company discontinues the new deluxe air filter, customers will resume buying its economy filter. This assumption may not be correct. Customers who prefer the deluxe model may do so because it requires replacement less often. Thus, instead of buying the companys economy filters again, these customers may just as likely turn to a competitor for a product similar to the deluxe model. In this event, the result would be lower profits.
Secondly, the marketing department fails to recognize alternative strategies that might enhance profits more than discontinuing the deluxe filter would. It is possible that lowering the price of the economy model, raising the price of the deluxe model, or both, may actually maximize profits. A lower-priced economy filter might lure customers from competing products and retain current customers. At the same time, buyers of the deluxe model may place a premium value on its convenience and may be willing to pay an even higher price for the filter.
Thirdly, the marketing department unfairly assumes that the availability of its deluxe filter is the cause of decreasing profits. It is equally possible that other factors, such as increased competition or supply prices, or decreased demand for these kinds of filters generally, are responsible for the decrease in profits. If so, discontinuing the deluxe filter may not serve to maximize, or even enhance, the companys profits.
In conclusion, the departments argument for discontinuing the deluxe filter is weak because the department has not considered the possible adverse consequences of doing so, or the alternatives to doing so. Moreover, the department has failed to establish a clear causal connection between the availability of the deluxe filter and decreasing profits. To strengthen its argument, the department must consider and rule out pricing adjustments as a better strategy to maximize profits, and must provide better evidence that the deluxe filter is the cause of the decrease in profits.
2009中考英语备考复习指导之语法集锦
2009中考英语备考攻略——快速突破听力
09中考备考宝典之英语短语集中联想记忆汇总(五)
09中考英语复习备考策略:抓技巧找目标快提高
备考专家:中考英语冲刺高分四大妙招
09中考备考宝典之英语短语集中联想记忆汇总(二)
中考冲刺复习:英语听读背三结合
09中考英语阅读完形写作答题指南
2009年北京中考英语单项选择模拟题
中考英语前一个月回归基础更重要
初中英语作文范文两篇
中考英语如何吃透模拟题拿的最高分?
09中考备考宝典之英语短语集中联想记忆汇总(三)
名师指点:中考英语听力听力满分攻略
中考英语备考宝典——名师讲解非谓语动词考点
八一中学初三英语优秀作文:.书信
中考英语考前一个月如何复习?
2009年中考英语复习七年级下册
2009英语中考备考复习之部分否定的七种表示方法
中考英语词汇复习:a bit & a little的区别
2009年武汉市中考英语备考建议
中考英语语法考点导练系列——名词
2009英语中考备考复习之主动语态变被动语态
中考英语最后一个月复习:回归课本研究真题
2009中考英语考试说明解读:阅读理解将成拉分题
09中考备考宝典之英语短语集中联想记忆汇总(四)
2009北京中考英语考生考前必读
英语备考复习之中考考点回顾
中考英语写作如何"妙笔生花"?
09中考备考秘笈 英语阅读理解带着问题找答案
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |