73. The following appeared as part of a memorandum from a government agency.
Given the limited funding available for the building and repair of roads and bridges, the government should not spend any money this year on fixing the bridge that crosses the Styx River. This bridge is located near a city with a weakening economy, so it is not as important as other bridges; moreover, the city population is small and thus unlikely to contribute a significant enough tax revenue to justify the effort of fixing the bridge.
Discuss how well reasoned... etc.
The author of this government agency memorandum argues that the government should not spend any money this year fixing the bridge that crosses the Styx River, given the limited resources available for building and repair of roads and bridges. The author reasons that this bridge is less important than others because it is located near a city with a weakening economy, and because the citys small population is unlikely to contribute enough tax revenue to Justify fixing their bridge. This argument is unconvincing for four reasons.
First of all, the author unfairly assumes that the importance of a bridge is determined solely by the economic condition of nearby cities. This assumption overlooks other criteria for determining a bridges importance―such as the number of commuters using the bridge, the role of the bridge in local emergencies and disasters, and the impact that bridge closure would have on the economies of nearby cities. Without accounting for these other potential factors, the author fails to provide a convincing argument that the Styx River Bridge is unimportant.
Secondly, the author fails to provide any evidence that other bridges are more important than the Styx River Bridge. Without such evidence, we cannot accept the authors conclusion that no government funds should be directed toward maintaining the Styx River Bridge.
Thirdly, the fact that the nearby city has a weakening economy does not prove that the city will not contribute significantly to tax revenues. Perhaps tax revenues are based on property taxes, which are not related directly to economic conditions. If so, and if property values and taxes are high in this nearby city, then the city would contribute significantly to tax revenues, and the bridge would be important to maintain those property values and the revenues they generate.
Finally, the author assumes that a city should receive government services commensurate with the tax dollars it contributes. Substantiating this assumption requires examining the proper duty of government. However, the author provides no such examination. Accordingly, this assumption is simply an unproven claim.
In conclusion, this editorial fails to substantiate its claim that the Styx River Bridge is not important enough for the government to spend tax dollars to maintain and repair it. To strengthen the argument, the author must account for other factors that also determine a bridges importance, and must compare the importance of this bridge relative to other bridges.
初中三年级英语阅读 阅读理解及答案解析(十一)
初二英语阅读题专项练习:屠夫和狗
初二英语阅读题专项练习:二战的故事
初三英语作文:My Dream School_800字
2013中考英语阅读真题特训及答案解析
初二英语阅读题专项练习:圣诞节礼物
圣诞节购物小贴士 12种购物陷阱要当心
初中三年级英语阅读 阅读理解及答案解析(六)
初中三年级英语阅读 阅读理解及答案解析(五)
初二英语阅读题专项练习:梦
初二英语阅读题专项练习:成就伟大科学家的秘密
初二英语阅读题专项练习:灵感
初二英语阅读题专项练习:出租车司机
初三开学英语测评之阅读试题和答案
初中三年级英语阅读 阅读理解及答案解析(七)
初中三年级英语阅读 阅读理解及答案解析(一)
初二英语阅读题专项练习:单词意义的转变
初中二年级英语阅读 阅读理解(三)
初二英语阅读题专项练习:森林覆盖率
初中二年级英语阅读 阅读理解(一)
初二年级英语阅读理解专项练习
初中二年级英语阅读 阅读理解(四)
初二英语阅读题专项练习:因特网的历史
初三英语阅读理解模拟试题
初中三年级英语阅读 阅读理解及答案解析(三)
初二英语阅读题专项练习:关于时间的笑话
初中三年级英语阅读 阅读理解及答案解析(九)
初二英语阅读题专项练习:动物实验
初中三年级英语阅读 阅读理解及答案解析(八)
初二英语阅读题专项练习:丢失的火车票
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |