The following appeared in an article in the health section of a newspaper.
There is a common misconception that university hospitals are better than community or private hospitals. This notion is unfounded, however: the university hospitals in our region employ 15 percent fewer doctors, have a 20 percent lower success rate in treating patients, make far less overall profit, and pay their medical staff considerably less than do private hospitals. Furthermore, many doctors at university hospitals typically divide their time among teaching, conducting research, and treating patients. From this it seems clear that the quality of care at university hospitals is lower than that at other kinds of hospitals.
Discuss how well reasoned... etc.
In this argument the author concludes that university hospitals provide no better care than private or community hospitals. The author bases this conclusion on the following claims about university hospitals: the ones in this region employ 15 percent fewer doctors; they have a 20 percent lower success rate in treating patients; they pay their staffs less money; they make less profit than community hospitals; and they utilize doctors who divide their time between teaching, research and treating patients. This argument is unconvincing for several reasons.
The most egregious reasoning error in the argument is the authors use of evidence pertaining to university hospitals in this region as the basis for a generalization about all university hospitals. The underlying assumption operative in this inference is that university hospitals in this region are representative of all university hospitals. No evidence is offered to support this gratuitous assumption.
Secondly, the only relevant reason offered in support of the claim that the quality of care is lower in university hospitals than it is at other hospitals is the fact that university hospitals have a lower success rate in treating patients. But this reason is not sufficient to reach the conclusion in question unless it can be shown that the patients treated in both types of hospitals suffered from similar types of maladies. For example, if university hospitals routinely treat patients suffering from rare diseases whereas other hospitals treat only those who suffer from known diseases and illnesses, the difference in success rates would not be indicative of the quality of care received.
Finally, the author assumes that the number of doctors a hospital employs, its success rate in treating patients, the amount it pays its staff, and the profits it earns are all reliable indicators of the quality of care it delivers. No evidence is offered to support this assumption nor is it obvious that any of these factors is linked to the quality of care delivered to patients. Moreover, the fact that doctors in university hospitals divide their time among many tasks fails to demonstrate that they do a poorer job of treating patients than doctors at other kinds of hospitals. In fact, it is highly likely that they do a better job because they are more knowledgeable than other doctors due to their teaching and research.
In conclusion, the authors argument is unconvincing. To strengthen the argument the author would have to demonstrate that university hospitals in this region are representative of all university hospitals, as well as establishing a causal link between the various factors cited and the quality of care delivered to patients.
09年英语短语集中联想记忆110条
初中英语 词缀记忆法
2010年中考英语词汇旧词新义:blind
2010年中考英语词汇熟词新义:start
2009中考英语词汇表 系列I
词汇笔记 五种词汇的学习方法 超强
高中英语词汇:80后“A到Z”生存法则
2010年中考英语词汇旧词新义:deal
2009中考英语词汇表 系列H
中考英语词汇“for短语”全攻略
“爱”成中学生作文出现频率最高词汇
初中英语常用词组复习2
2009中考英语词汇表 系列M
中考英语词汇--“美味水果”大聚会
09年中考英语总复习经典习题讲解2一名词
初中英语常用词组2 介词短语词组
2009中考英语词汇表 系列UV
常用英语词语辨析105组(4)
09年中考英语总复习经典习题讲解5一代词
初中英语常用词组复习1
2009中考英语词汇表 系列T
常用英语词语辨析105组(5)
2010年中考英语词汇旧词新义:clean
为英语写作”画龙点睛“的24句谚语
初中英语常用词组3 量词词组
常用英语词语辨析105组(11)
09年中考英语总复习经典习题讲解4一数词
2009中考英语词汇表 系列O
2010年中考英语词汇旧词新义:cost
2009中考英语词汇表 系列R
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |