23. The following appeared in a speech delivered by a member of the city council.
Twenty years ago, only half of the students who graduated from Einstein High School went on to attend a college or university. Today, two thirds of the students who graduate from Einstein do so. Clearly, Einstein has improved its educational effectiveness over the past two decades. This improvement has occurred despite the fact that the schools funding, when adjusted for inflation, is about the same as it was twenty years ago. Therefore, we do not need to make any substantial increase in the schools funding at this time.
Discuss how well reasoned... etc.
This speaker draws the conclusion that there is no need to substantially increase funding for Einstein High School. To support this conclusion, the speaker claims that Einstein has improved its educational efficiency over the past 20 years, even though funding levels have remained relatively constant. His evidence is that two-thirds of Einsteins graduates now go on to college, whereas 20 years ago only half of its students did so. This argument suffers from several critical problems.
To begin with, we must establish the meaning of the vague concept educational efficiency. If the term is synonymous with the rate of graduation to college, then the statistics cited would strongly support the argument. But, normally we are interested in something more than just the numbers of students who go on to college from a high school; we also want to know how well the school has prepared students for a successful college experiencethat is, whether the school has provided a good secondary education. Thus, for the speaker the term educational efficiency must essentially carry the same meaning as educational quality.
Given this clarification, one of the speakers assumptions is that the rate of graduation to college has increased because Einstein is doing a better job of educating its students. However, the fact that more Einstein graduates now go on to college might simply reflect a general trend. And the general trend might have less to do with improved secondary education than with the reality that a college degree is now the standard of entry into most desirable jobs.
But even if the quality of education at Einstein had improved, would this be a compelling reason to deny Einstein additional funding? I dont think so. It is possible that the school has managed to deliver better education in spite of meager funding. Teachers may be dipping into their own pockets for supplies and other resources necessary for doing their job well. Perhaps the quality of education at Einstein would improve even more with additional financial support.
In sum, this argument does not establish the conclusion that additional funding for Einstein is unnecessary. To do so, the speaker would have to provide evidence that the quality of education at Einstein has improved. This could be done by examining student assessment scores or by tracking students through their college careers to see how many successfully graduate and find jobs. In addition, the speaker would also have to show that Einstein is doing a good job with adequate financial support, and not merely in spite of insufficient funding.
名师考试方法精讲之十四:四级考试十点注意
名师考试方法精讲之四十二:四级阅读题如何得高分
英语四级66分经验分享
英语四级学习方法指导:四大逻辑关系之对比转折关系
考试经验:冲刺英语四级英语考试应分块来复习
名师考试方法精讲之八:考试四大板块
名师考试方法精讲之四十:大学英语四级学习方法
大学英语考试经验谈:四级备考各阶段注意要点
名师考试方法精讲之二十八:应试学习技巧
名师考试方法精讲之二十二:写作突破经验
名师考试方法精讲之二十一:词汇记忆
四级考试技巧
大学四级考试过关经验谈:往年真题是最好的参考资料
大学英语四级考试经验:如何应对英语四级改错
英语考试秘笈:大学四级英语备考易见问题及正确应对
名师考试方法精讲之五:英语四级冲刺方法
名师考试方法精讲之四十三:四级词汇阅读题怎么得高分
考友经验秘传:备考英语四级关键要靠执着
英语四级学习方法指导:四大逻辑关系之因果关系
名师考试方法精讲之四十七:四级备考各阶段注意要点
名师考试方法精讲之十三:英语四级过关绝招
大学英语高分通过四级:功在平时
名师考试方法精讲之六:详解翻译
英语考试秘笈:英语四级考试这样过级
如何才能在短时间通过英语四级:英语四级考试经验
名师考试方法精讲之十六:怎么复习听力
名师指点:大学英语四级开始如何备考
名师考试方法精讲之十八:浅谈四级作文
考试经验介绍:英语四级考试不过的三大原因
名师考试方法精讲之二十九:英语四级听力调整心态重要
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |