It is often necessary, even desirable, for political leaders to withhold information from the public.
I agree with the speaker that it is sometimes necessary, and even desirable, for political leaders to withhold information from the public. A contrary view would reveal a naivetd about the inherent nature of public politics, and about the sorts of compromises on the part of well-intentioned political leaders necessary in order to further the publics ultmaate interests. Nevertheless, we must not allow our political leaders undue freedom to with-hold information, otherwise, we risk sanctioning demagoguery and undermining the philosophical underpinnings of any democratic society.
One reason for my fundamental agreement with the speaker is that in order to gain the opportunity for effective public leadership, a would-be leader must fzrst gain and maintain political power. In the game of politics, complete forthrightness is a sign of vulnerability and naivete, neither of which earn a politician respect among his or her opponents, and which those opponents will use to every advantage to defeat the politician. In my observation some measure of pandering to the electorate is necessary to gain and maintain political leadership. For example, were all politicians to fully disclose every personal foibles, character flaw, and detail concerning personal life, few honest politicians would ever by elected. While this view might seem cynical, personal scandals have in fact proven the undoing of many a political career; thus I think this view is realistic.
Another reason why I essentially agree with the speaker is that fully disclosing to the public certain types of information would threaten public safety and perhaps even national security. For example, if the President were to disclose the governments strategies for thwarting specific plans of an international terrorist or a drug trafficker, those strategies would surely fail, and the publics health and safety would be compromised as a result. Withholding information might also be necessary to avoid public panic. While such cases are rare, they do occur
occasionally. For example, during the first few hours of the new millennium the U.S. Pentagons missile defense system experienced a Y2K- related malfunction. This fact was withheld from the public until later in the day, once the problem had been solved; and legitimately so, since immediate disclosure would have served no useful purpose and might even have resulted in mass hysteria.
Having recognized that withholding informarion from the public is often necessary to serve the interests of that public, legitimate political leadership nevertheless requires forthrightness with the citizenry as to the leaders motives and agenda. History informs us that would-be leaders who lack such forthrightness are the same ones who seize and maintain power either by brute force or by demagoguery--that is, by deceiving and manipulating the citizenry. Paragons such as Genghis Khan and Hitler, respectively, come immediately to mind. Any democratic society should of course abhor demagoguery, which operates against the democratic principle of government by the people. Consider also less egregious examples, such as President Nixons withholding of information about his active role in the Watergate cover-up. His behavior demonstrated a concern for self- interest above the broader interests of the democratic system that granted his political authority in the first place.
In sum, the game of politics calls for a certain amount of disingenuousness and lack of forthrightness that we might otherwise characterize as dishonesty. And such behavior is a necessary means to the final objective of effective political leadership. Nevertheless, in any democracy a leader who relies chiefly on deception and secrecy to preserve that leadership, to advance a private agenda, or to conceal selfish motives, betrays the democracy-and ends up forfeiting the polirical game.
2009中考英语词汇表 系列M
2009中考英语词汇表 系列T
2009中考英语词汇短语集锦 (2)
2009中考英语词汇表 系列R
初中英语常用词组复习2
十个窍门积累英语词汇
词汇笔记 五种词汇的学习方法 超强
常用英语词语辨析105组(3)
常用英语词语辨析105组(11)
2010年中考英语词汇熟词新义:start
常用英语词语辨析105组(4)
中考英语词汇--“美味水果”大聚会
中考英语词汇“for短语”全攻略
2009中考英语词汇表 系列UV
2009中考英语词汇表 系列I
09年中考英语总复习经典习题讲解1一冠词
2009中考英语词汇表 系列H
2009最新中考英语单项填空模拟考试卷 附详解答案
常用英语词语辨析105组(5)
2009中考英语词汇表 系列O
为英语写作”画龙点睛“的24句谚语
高中英语词汇:80后“A到Z”生存法则
英乐时空Here I Am
初中英语常用词组1 动词词组
初中英语短语汇总 A- Y
09年中考英语总复习经典习题讲解4一数词
初中英语常用词组复习1
初中英语 词缀记忆法
张惠妹《排山倒海》英文版
2010年中考英语词汇旧词新义:clean
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |