雅思阅读:Reviving autopsy
TECHNOLOGY advances not only through new inventions, but also by the imaginative application of old ones. And one of the most ancient forms of scientific investigation, the post-mortem autopsy, may be ripe for just such a technological upgrade. According to a paper in this weeks Lancet, published by Ian Roberts of the John Radcliffe Hospital, in Oxford, it may soon be time to put away the scalpel and the retractor clamp, and to replace them with the body scanner.
The study of death is never a cheerful topic, but it has gone through a particularly gloomy patch over the past few decades. A recent tally by Americas Centres for Disease Control and Prevention showed that in 2007 only 8.5% of deaths in America were investigated by autopsy. In 1972 that figure was 19.3%. Britains coroners are more active, but perhaps not more accurate. Twenty-two percent of deaths in the United Kingdom lead to an autopsy. According to a government review, however, one in four is of miserable quality. The upshot in both cases is not just that the cause of individual deaths may be misascribed. More seriously, data about the processes of disease are lost, and those diseases are thus not as well understood as they might have been. Squeamish relatives of the deceased, too, often do not like the idea of bodies being cut up at the behest of coroners. Britains health department therefore commissioned Dr Roberts to study whether scanning dead bodies in the way that is routine for living ones would help. His conclusion is that it would.
Rather than slicing the body with a knife, scanning slices them with radiation. Computerised tomography uses X-rays to collect information from many angles, and a lot of processing power to convert that information into cross-sectional images of a bodys inner tissues. In forensic cases CT scans are often used to spot fractures and haemorrhages. Dr Roberts found them adept at noticing diseased arteries, as well. The other widespread scanning technique, magnetic-resonance imaging , uses radio waves and is best suited for exploring the detail of soft tissues.
Though both of these technologies have been around for a long time, they have had only limited use in autopsies. Americas authorities conduct CT scans of dead soldiersbut such scans are employed to augment traditional post mortems, not replace them. Some coroners in England, spurred on by the religious objections of Jews and Muslims, do allow scans rather than conventional autopsies in certain cases. But the accuracy of these scans is unknown. Dr Roberts is the first to provide data on whether scanning might replace conventional methods.
He and his colleagues examined 182 bodies in Manchester and Oxford. Radiologists studied CT and MRI scans of these bodies, made diagnoses based on them, explained their confidence in these diagnoses, and judged whether the scans might thus preclude the need for a full autopsy. Within 12 hours of each scan, a pathologist then performed a conventional autopsy, so that Dr Roberts could compare the new methods with the old.
The scans were far from perfect. The rate of discrepancy between the cause of death, as determined by radiology and as determined by conventional autopsy, was 32% for CT scans, 43% for MRI and 30% for a combination of CT and MRI. Most troubling, the scans had difficulty showing heart disease, a common killer. However, radiologists were good at identifying which diagnoses were sound and which needed to be re-evaluated by a full autopsy. When they felt confident in their diagnoseswhich was the case for 34% of CT investigations and 42% of MRIsthe discrepancy between the results from scanning and those from autopsies was lower. For CT scans, it was just 16%.
That is still a significant gap, of course. But not all of it is caused because traditional methods are better. For one body, for example, scanning revealed a lethal stroke that dissection missed.All this suggests that scans might play a useful role in determining causes of death. When a radiologist is confident in the diagnosis from a scan, a traditional autopsy might be unnecessary. When he is less confident, his scan could still be a useful guide for the wielder of the knife.
Automating autopsies by using scanners might also make them cheaper, by speeding the process up. And it could be done with otherwise-redundant machines that have been replaced for use on live patients with modern devices which give off less radiation. That would get rid of the need to buy new kit to cope with the extra demand for scans. A thorough study of the costs of both approaches would be needed, of course, and traditional autopsies are unlikely to disappear completely. But for some deaths, a scan will likely prove better than a scalpel.
考研英语阅读篇章摩根大通老板杰米戴蒙患咽喉癌
考研英语阅读篇章游泳猪蹿红网络变身加勒比沙滩宝贝
考研英语阅读篇章印度集体童婚七岁女童嫁十六岁男孩
2015考研英语时事分类词汇中日关系
考研英语阅读篇章阿里巴巴将在美国开网店
考研英语阅读篇章非洲就埃博拉病毒爆发
考研英语阅读篇章里约大冒险蓝鹦鹉原型去世
考研英语阅读篇章深海潜水能手智利魔鬼鱼
考研英语阅读篇章男子掰弯车门框解救被困司机
考研英语阅读篇章老板使用社交媒体比员工多
考研英语阅读篇章覆水难收
考研英语阅读篇章芬兰宝宝为何睡纸板箱
考研英语阅读篇章草莓是最快乐的水果
考研英语阅读篇章论友谊
考研英语阅读篇章英女王超长待机五十多年只穿一双鞋
考研英语阅读篇章你被社交媒体绑架了吗
考研英语阅读篇章中韩影星跨国恋汤唯蔡琳双双订婚
考研英语阅读篇章中国队缺席世界杯但球迷热情不减
考研英语阅读真题文章三十篇之二十六
考研英语阅读篇章科学家发现新物种圆耳象鼩
考研英语阅读篇章六月中国制造业增长上半年最高
考研英语阅读篇章论旅行
考研英语阅读篇章太阳能电池板可将二氧化碳转化为甲酸
考研英语阅读篇章谷歌员工女儿写信替爸爸请假获一周假
考研英语阅读篇章失联马航最新调查报告
考研英语阅读篇章淡定八旬夫妇爱自拍翻车先拍照后逃生
考研英语阅读篇章做外星人认识的第一个地球人
考研英语阅读篇章奥巴马讲话帮助美国莘莘学子
考研英语阅读篇章哈利波特对角巷公园开放
考研英语阅读篇章苏亚雷斯又咬人舌尖上的苏牙
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |