There are often media reports of events in which issues of ethics are involved. These reports often trigger debates among media critics and Internet surfers. In the debates, "human nature" and "human right" are frequently mentioned. In many cases, however, these two concepts are abused.
A few days ago, a teacher posted an article at the www.tianya.cn website telling of his experience in the earthquake that struck Sichuan on May 12. He was giving a lecture in a classroom on an upper floor of a middle school in Dujiangyan when the building trembled. He dashed out of the classroom and hurried downstairs to the playground to find that he was the first to have escaped to safety.
Later, answering a student who accused him of leaving his pupils behind in danger, he said: "I am one who pursues freedom and fairness rather than one who will sacrifice his life to save others. Faced with the choice between life and death, I would possibly consider to sacrifice my life only if it were to save my daughter; I wouldn't care about anybody else even if she was my mother." He then said: "This may sound like finding excuses for myself, but I haven't the slightest sense of guilt."
His frank confession triggered strong responses from the netizens. While most voiced their indignation at the man's "betrayal of teachers' professional ethics", many expressed sympathy for his "involuntary act of human nature" and argued for his "human right" to protect himself. They said the man should not be blamed.
I agree that the man is not legally culpable but I do not think he is completely unblamable.
Admittedly, anyone has the right to stay away from danger when his/her life is threatened. But the man's situation was not simply one where life confronts nature. He was a teacher and his students were in great danger when he ran away alone. Though he was not legally bound to the obligation, protecting students from danger should have been his instinctive reaction when danger struck.
In the May 12 earthquake, scores of teachers died protecting their students from falling buildings. When excavated from the debris, they were all found in the same posture - spreading their arms to shield the children under their bodies. I believe they did so out of a teacher's instinct. They could not have given a thought to anything else in a split second, be it a legal right or an ethical virtue.
Maybe we who did not experience the quake are not eligible to blame the escaped teacher but his act was certainly a deplorable contrast to his colleagues' heroic acts.
More contemptible is his flaunting of his contempt of a man's bravery of protecting the weak - children and elderly - and his unconditional pursuit of "personal freedom". In the 6,100-word article he posted online, a fairly large part was devoted to the defense of this personal freedom.
Those who cited "human nature" and "human right" to defend the man are also deplorable. Perhaps they meant to show how they were impartial and cool-minded amid the nation's passionate support of the heroic deeds of the locals of the quake-stricken areas and the rescuers from across the country. But they were actually confusing right and wrong over the issue of ethics. Most representative of these people was the one who cited the Law on Teachers, which does not rule that a teacher is responsible to protect students in case of natural disasters. "Therefore," the defender said, "the teacher is not blamable."
This is a ridiculous logic, for being legally inculpable does not mean ethically righteous. Those who try to show they are more "civilized" by mocking the public's common sense of righteousness are actually ridiculing themselves.
A bitter pill to swallow 不得不吞的苦药
California wildfires and cloned animals 加利福尼亚州野火,克隆动物衰老过程正常
US-Cuba flights and male cosmetic surgery 美国-古巴复航和男性整容手术
World's longest tunnel and a strange kind of race 世界最长铁路隧道,扛羊毛袋比赛
India's sewer workers and British school standards 印度下水道工人施工安全,英国在校生学习成绩下降
Crash course 速成课
Zuma in court and stressed horses 南非总统受审和马的精神压力
In one ear and out the other 左耳进,右耳出
Artefacts in Sydney and dog gets medal 悉尼出土文物,英雄狗获奖章
All things to all people 八面玲珑
Antibiotics and escalator etiquette 美国人过多使用抗生素,伦敦地铁扶梯礼仪
Drought in Ethiopia and MS treatment 埃塞俄比亚干旱,多发性硬化治疗手段新进展
Counting elephants, Australian Elvis 空中数大象,澳大利亚“猫王节”
Angelina Jolie to divorce, Karaoke star at 80 安吉丽娜·朱莉提出离婚申请,八十岁老人出唱片
Cyclists make Olympic history, 400-year-old shark 英国自行车运动员创英奥运历史,400岁格陵兰鲨鱼
The cost of protecting the environment, Juno space probe 保护环境付出的代价,“朱诺”木星探测器
EU after Brexit, human ancestor mystery 英脱欧公投后的欧盟,人类祖先之谜新发现
Alligator takes boy and Tate Modern extension 鳄鱼拖走小男孩,泰特现代美术馆扩建完工
Phelps makes history and marine species 菲尔普斯创造历史,海洋新物种
Canada wildfire and NASA discovery 加拿大林火,美国国家航空航天局发现系外行星
Indian state introduces 'fat tax' 印度一省拟征收“脂肪税”
Zika threat and back from space 寨卡病毒威胁美国,国际空间站宇航员返回地球
Zika virus, Rare whale filmed in Australia 寨卡病毒传播风险,澳大利亚拍到罕见鲸鱼影像
Art and football 海底发现文物,莱斯特城足球俱乐部曼谷庆功
Battery risk, Farmer anti-theft solution 纽扣电池的潜在危险,牧场主防盗有术
Darkness over Indonesia and the 'fifth Beatle' dies 印度尼西亚日全食,“第五位披头士”去世
Brexit and Hockney's art 英国脱欧公投后进展,大卫·霍克尼艺术展
Chinwag 闲谈-英语点津
Big Ben and gorilla surprise 维修大本钟,大猩猩生子
IOC on Russian doping and hot June 奥委会就涉俄兴奋剂事件报告进展,六月高温破纪录
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |