There is a group of people in this country who regard themselves as the "elites of society". They take themselves to be the most advanced part of society in China's progress toward modernity. They always try to distinguish themselves from the public by saying something special. Their most favorite tactic is to publish an opinion that challenges the masses' common sense. They are best at exaggerating a situation to produce a sensational effect.
A recent event gave them such a chance.
Fan Meizhong, a middle school teacher in Sichuan, ran away from a soon-to-collapse classroom when the earthquake struck, leaving his students behind. His act provoked widespread criticism on the Internet and in the media. Most critics remarked that he had violated the professional ethics of a teacher though his involuntary dodging of danger was understandable as a human being.
Meanwhile, quite a number of people expressed their sympathy for Fan. They placed more emphasis on the need to forgive the weaker side of human nature. They surely have reasons to hold this opinion. And it is reassuring to hear a different voice in the unanimous criticism against Fan, for it represents an effort to create a democratic atmosphere in the circle of critics.
Some people, however, went too far in defying the public sentiment. They challenged the mainstream opinion by accusing it of "moral autocracy". One of them published a commentary titled "Can we become more noble by defaming Fan"?
The commentator, who gave his surname as Cao, said the critical remarks on the Internet forums "generally demonstrated an excessively excited sentiment of moral trial". He debunked the online criticism as a "moral campaign the pseudo moralists and young radicals have waged in order to erect a chastity arch (to honor themselves)".
These words show that Cao was targeting at the whole community of Fan's critics.
He based his argument on the assumption that everybody has the same "weakness" in his/her innermost soul as Fan displayed. Therefore, he said, people should not blame Fan but should instead regard him as an excusable pal and "reflect on the human weakness together with Fan". He urged Fan's critics to "approach him rather than abandon him; understand him rather than wantonly vilify him".
Cao was wrong in his argument at least on three points. First, not everybody will behave the same way Fan did, as suggested by Cao. This has been proved by thousands of people who bravely saved others in the quake risking their own lives.
Second, the fact that most people have the same human weakness does not mean that they are not eligible to criticize Fan. People condemned him out of their understanding of what is morally right and wrong. Do they need to do something heroic before they start criticizing Fan?
Third, Fan's critics did not blame him for being afraid of death but for ignoring his students' safety and claiming that he would even abandon his mother in the same situation.
An ugly behavior was made known to the public and the public expressed their disapproval, or even anger, at the behavior. This is only too natural. What traces of "autocracy" can one find in the critical remarks? It is true that some of the critics used harsh words in denouncing Fan. But such unwanted expressions are understandable, given Fan's shameless showing off of his behavior. They are far from "brandishing a moral club" to "kill" Fan, as Cao alleged them to be in his commentary.
Like other "social elites", Cao "imagines himself as a safeguard of justice" - to quote Cao's own words in his criticism of Fan's critics - and tries to teach the public a lesson about democracy and human rights. Regrettably, the public do not want to hear their garrulous preaching; they have seen through the hypocrites.
英语美文:一双丝袜(有声)
精选英语美文阅读:饶孟侃《呼唤》
精选英语美文阅读:假如生活欺骗了你
精选英语散文欣赏:微笑挽救生命
英语美文:A Psalm of Life 人生礼颂
精选英语美文阅读:A Friend's Prayer 朋友的祈祷
英文《小王子》温情语录
双语阅读:回家的感觉真好
双语美文:What are you still waiting for?
26个英文字母蕴含的人生哲理
精美散文:爱你所做 做你所爱
最美的英文情诗:请允许我成为你的夏季
浪漫英文情书精选:Keep You Forever永远温存着你
美文欣赏:海边漫步
如果生命可以重来(双语)
双语美文:I Wish I Could believe
精选英语美文阅读:被忽略的爱 Helpless love
英语名篇名段背诵精华27
精美散文:让我们撩起生命的波纹
浪漫英文情书精选:My Everything我的一切
浪漫英文情书精选:Is It Love?这是爱么?
精选英语散文欣赏:一棵小苹果树
浪漫英文情书精选:Need You With Me需要你爱我
精选英语美文阅读:无雨的梅雨天 (双语)
英语晨读:潘多拉
浪漫英文情书精选:Don't Give Up不要放弃
英语美文:越长大越孤独(双语)
浪漫英文情书精选:Could This Be Real?这是真的吗?
精美散文:守护自己的天使
双语美文欣赏:孤独人生
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |