The Maysville Road veto occurred on May 27, 1830 when President Andrew Jackson vetoed a bill which would allow the Federal government to purchase stock in the Maysville, Washington, Paris, and Lexington Turnpike Road Company, which had been organized to construct a road linking Lexington and the Ohio River, the entirety of which would be in the state of Kentucky. Its advocates regarded it as a part of the national Cumberland Road system. Congress passed a bill in 1830 providing federal funds to complete the project. Jackson vetoed the bill on the grounds that federal funding of intrastate projects of this nature was unconstitutional. He declared that such bills violated the principle that the government shouldnt be an economic affair. Jackson also pointed out that funding for these kinds of projects interfered with the paying off of the national debt.
Proponents of internal improvements, such as the development of roads and bridges, argued that the federal government had an obligation to harmonize the nations diverse, and often conflicting, sectional interests into an American System. Jacksons decision was heavily influenced by his Vice President Martin Van Buren. Some authors have described the motives behind the veto decision as personal, rather than political. The veto has been attributed to a personal grudge against Henry Clay, as well as to preserve the trade monopoly of the Erie Canal, in the case of Van Buren.
Debate in Congress
Supporters of the bill insisted on the projects national significance. This particular project was intended to be a part of a much larger interstate system extending from Zanesville, Ohio to Florence, Alabama. If the highway as a whole was of national significance, they argued, surely the individual sections must be, as well. They looked to the Supreme Court decision handed down six years before in Gibbons v Ogden, in which the court confirmed the power to regulate commerce among the states including those portions of the journey which lay within one state or another. Additionally, the road connected the interior of Kentucky to the Ohio river, and therefore served as the main artery for the transportation of goods. Kentucky Representative Robert Letcher made this argument regarding the roads connection to the rest of the nation:
The road designed to be improved is intended to intersect the great national road in the State of Ohio. It connects itself also on each side with the Ohio River. These two connexions most certainly and justly entitle it to the appellation of a national work.
Moreover, the federal government had provided funding for other intrastate projects when they benefited the rest of the nation. As Representative Coleman stated:
But gentlemen say, every inch of the Maysville road is in the State of Kentucky. How can it be national? I answer, every inch of the Delaware Canal, sixteen miles in length, is in the State of New Jersey; and every inch of the Louisville Canal is in one county; nay, I believe in one city. How can they be national? Yet, Congress have subscribed for stock in both of them.
These arguments were all intended to illustrate the roads overwhelming national significance. Opponents responded that this line of argument would establish every road a national road; there would be no limit to federal power.
教你如何写出具有雅思范儿的高分作文
2016年英语四级考试作文模板
新GRE填空题题型解析——动物类题型
Long before the scientific world became 阅读理解答案
新GRE填空题备考策略:双重否定问题的解析
备战新SAT语法考试,你怎能不知逗号的正确使用方法
2016年北京高考英语作文题目:地球日
四六级有用的短语
29首英文歌,帮你轻松提高雅思口语成绩
教你三步轻松搞定GRE填空题
2016年福建高考英语作文题目
雅思口语:2015年总结及2016年备考规划
新GRE填空小妙招揭秘之由前及后法
新SAT备考指南:这样备考助你冲高分
2016年英语四级听力中最常见的五类问题
GRE填空小妙招:句子填空的特殊解法
选择这些美国大学,你就不用备考SAT了
雅思写作中,最让人爱不起的十大开头
GRE句子填空解题小技巧揭密
雅思写作:教育类词汇大盘点
揭秘新GRE:填空题目的出题特点
A trip to London My family had dreamed of a trip to London for阅读理解答案
Attention to detail is something everyone can阅读理解答案
Love is a hot topic, but what is love Here is a story.完形填空答案
雅思口语发音小技巧,叫你轻松说英语
2016年英语四级听力题型调整情况分析
论新SAT文法中,标点符号的重要性
备战GRE,不得不看的六类资料
Do you like to visit the zoo in our city?Zoo 完形填空答案
新GRE填空小妙招揭秘之因果关系法
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |