The Triumph of Unreason
A.
Neoclassical economics is built on the assumption that humans are rational beings who have a clear idea of their best interests and strive to extract maximum benefit from any situation. Neoclassical economics assumes that the process of decision-making is rational. But that contradicts growing evidence that decision-making draws on the emotionseven when reason is clearly involved.
B.
The role of emotions in decisions makes perfect sense. For situations met frequently in the past, such as obtaining food and mates, and confronting or fleeing from threats, the neural mechanisms required to weigh up the pros and cons will have been honed by evolution to produce an optimal outcome. Since emotion is the mechanism by which animals are prodded towards such outcomes, evolutionary and economic theory predict the same practical consequences for utility in these cases. But does this still apply when the ancestral machinery has to respond to the stimuli of urban modernity?
C.
One of the people who thinks that it does not is George Loewenstein, an economist at Carnegie Mellon University, in Pittsburgh. In particular, he suspects that modern shopping has subverted the decision-making machinery in a way that encourages people to run up debt. To prove the point he has teamed up with two psychologists, Brian Knutson of Stanford University and Drazen Prelec of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, to look at what happens in the brain when it is deciding what to buy.
D
In a study, the three researchers asked 26 volunteers to decide whether to buy a series of products such as a box of chocolates or a DVD of the television show that were flashed on a computer screen one after another. In each round of the task, the researchers first presented the product and then its price, with each step lasting four seconds. In the final stage, which also lasted four seconds, they asked the volunteers to make up their minds. While the volunteers were taking part in the experiment, the researchers scanned their brains using a technique called functional magnetic resonance imaging 。 This measures blood flow and oxygen consumption in the brain, as an indication of its activity.
E.
The researchers found that different parts of the brain were involved at different stages of the test. The nucleus accumbens was the most active part when a product was being displayed. Moreover, the level of its activity correlated with the reported desirability of the product in question.
F.
When the price appeared, however, fMRI reported more activity in other parts of the brain. Excessively high prices increased activity in the insular cortex, a brain region linked to expectations of pain, monetary loss and the viewing of upsetting pictures. The researchers also found greater activity in this region of the brain when the subject decided not to purchase an item.
G.
Price information activated the medial prefrontal cortex, too. This part of the brain is involved in rational calculation. In the experiment its activity seemed to correlate with a volunteers reaction to both product and price, rather than to price alone. Thus, the sense of a good bargain evoked higher activity levels in the medial prefrontal cortex, and this often preceded a decision to buy.
H.
Peoples shopping behaviour therefore seems to have piggy-backed on old neural circuits evolved for anticipation of reward and the avoidance of hazards. What Dr Loewenstein found interesting was the separation of the assessment of the product from the assessment of its price , even though the two are then synthesised in the prefrontal cortex. His hypothesis is that rather than weighing the present good against future alternatives, as orthodox economics suggests happens, people actually balance the immediate pleasure of the prospective possession of a product with the immediate pain of paying for it.
I.
That makes perfect sense as an evolved mechanism for trading. If one useful object is being traded for another , the future utility of what is being given up is embedded in the object being traded.
Emotion is as capable of assigning such a value as reason. Buying on credit, though, may be different. The abstract nature of credit cards, coupled with the deferment of payment that they promise, may modulate the con side of the calculation in favour of the pro。
J.
Whether it actually does so will be the subject of further experiments that the three researchers are now designing. These will test whether people with distinctly different spending behaviour, such as miserliness and extravagance, experience different amounts of pain in response to prices. They will also assess whether, in the same individuals, buying with credit cards eases the pain compared with paying by cash. If they find that it does, then credit cards may have to join the list of things such as fatty and sugary foods, and recreational drugs, that subvert human instincts in ways that seem pleasurable at the time but can have a long and malign aftertaste. Questions 1-6 Do the following statemets reflect the claims of the writer in Reading Passage 1?
Write your answer in Boxes 1-6 on your answer sheet.
TRUE if the statement reflets the claims of the writer
FALSE if the statement contradicts the claims of the writer
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第55课:The Sawyer family索耶一家人
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第98课:Whose is it?
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第102课:He says he...
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第82课:I had...
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第81课:Roast beef and potatoes烤牛肉和土豆
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第58课:What’s the time?
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第84课:Have you had...?
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第87课:A car crash车祸
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第74课:What did they do?
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第60课:What’s the time?
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第72课:When did you...
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第69课:The car race汽车比赛
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第63课:Thank you, doctor.谢谢你,医生
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第71课:He’s awful!他讨厌透了!
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第78课:When did you...
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第92课:When will....?
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第95课:Tickets,please请把车票拿出来
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第93课:Our new neighbour 我们的新邻居
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第90课:Have you... yet?
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第61课:A bad cold重感冒
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第99课:Ow! 啊哟!
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第101课:A card from Jimmy吉米的明信片
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第73课:The way to King Street到国王街的走法
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第79课:Carol’s shopping list卡罗尔的购物单
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第66课:What’s the time?
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第94课:Will you go to...?
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第76课:When did you?
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第83课:Going on holiday度假
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第80课:I must go to the....
新概念英语第一册视频讲解 第89课:For sale待售