TOKYO, June 6 -- The Tokyo High Court on Thursday upheld a lower court ruling that ordered the Japanese government to pay compensation to residents suffering from aircraft noise near a U.S. air base in western Tokyo. But the court rejected their demand for flight suspension.
The court ordered the government to pay some 760 million yen (7 million U.S. dollars) to a group of more than 1,000 plaintiffs who live near the Yokota Air Base, which is shared with Japan's Air Self-Defense Force.
Presiding Judge Shigeru Nakanishi said, "The noise has led to emotional distress by disrupting daily life and causing discomfort, and has exceeded a tolerable level."
However, the compensation is to pay for the plaintiffs' sufferings in the past. The court turned down their demand for compensation for future damage. It also rejected the plaintiffs' demand for suspension of flights in early morning and at night.
A district court ruling in 2017 also awarded them compensation for past sufferings, but rejected payments for future damage and flight suspension.
In Thursday's ruling, the high court increased the amount of compensation to cover the sufferings after the district court ruling.
A leader of the plaintiffs, Toshimi Nakajima, said he was disappointed by the ruling as the noise pollution has worsened due to the deployment of the U.S. Osprey transport aircraft.
He said flight suspension is needed to stop the noise, adding that the plaintiffs will consider whether to appeal.
Yasuo Sekijima, the lawyer for the plaintiffs, indicated they would appeal the verdict, saying, "The lower court ruling was upheld unquestioningly. It denies future compensation and looks away from the fact that the unlawful conditions persist."
北师大版(三起)英语三年级上册期末试题1
[2012版]人教版(PEP)三上《Unit 4 We love animals》(Period Five)word随堂练习
北师大版(三起)英语三年级下册期末试题2
[2012版]人教版(PEP)三上《Unit 3 Look at me》word单元试卷(含听力)
北师大版(三起)英语三年级下册期末试题1
牛津苏教[2012秋]三上《Unit 3 My friends》word单元测试1
[2012版]人教版(PEP)三上《Unit 3 Look at me》word单元测试(含听力)
牛津苏教[2012秋]三上《Unit 1 Hello》word单元测试
牛津苏教[2012秋]三上《Unit 7 Would you like a pie》word单元测试
牛津苏教[2012秋]三上《Unit 8 Happy New Year》word单元测试
牛津苏教[2012秋]三上《Unit 4 My family》word单元测试
牛津苏教[2013版]英语三年级上册单元试题-Unit 1-2
[2012版]人教版(PEP)三上《Unit 3 Look at me》( Period Five)word随堂练习
牛津苏教[2012秋]三上《Unit 4 My family》word单元测试1
[2012版]人教版(PEP)三上《Unit 4 We love animals》(Period One)word随堂练习
[2012版]人教版(PEP)三上《Unit 3 Look at me》( Period One)word随堂练习
[2013秋]外研版(三起)三上《Module 1 Greetings》word模块练习题
[2013秋]外研版(三起)三上《Unit 2 How are you》word练习题
[2012版]人教版(PEP)三上《Unit 2 Colours》(Period One)word随堂练习
冀教版[2012秋]英语三年级上册期中试题
牛津苏教[2012秋]三上《Unit 6 Colours》word单元测试
冀教版[2012秋]英语三年级上册单元试题-Unit1-3
冀教版(三起)三上《Unit 1 School and Numbers》word单元测试
牛津苏教[2013版]英语三年级上册单元试题-Unit 1-3
[2012版]人教版(PEP)三上《Unit 3 Look at me》(Period Two)word随堂练习
牛津苏教[2012秋]三上《Unit 3 My friends》word单元测试
牛津苏教[2012秋]三上《Unit 2 I’m Liu Tao》word单元测试
[2012版]人教版(PEP)三上《Unit 2 Colours》(Period Six)word随堂练习
[2012版]人教版(PEP)三上《Unit 4 We love animals》(Period Three)word随堂练习
[2012版]人教版(PEP)三上《Unit 3 Look at me》( Period Four)word随堂练习