Helicopter Moms vs. Free-Range KidsWould you let your fourth-grader ride public transportation without an adult? Probably not. Still, when Lenore Skenazy, a columnist for the New York Sun, wrote about letting her son take the subway alone to get back to Long story short:my son got home from a department store on the Upper East Side, she didn t expect to get hit with a wave of criticism from readers.
Long story short: My son got home, overjoyed with independence, Skenazy wrote on April 4 in the New York Sun. Long story longer: Half the people I ve told this episode to now want to turn on in for child abuse. As if keeping kids under lock and key and cell phone and careful watch is the right way to rear kids. It s not. It s debilitating for us and for them.
Online message boards were soon full of people both applauding and condemning Skenazy s decision to let her son go it alone. She wound up defending herself on CNN and on popular blogs like the buffington post, where her follow-up piece was ironically headlined More From America s Worst Mom.
The episode has ignited another one of those debates that divides parents into vocal opposing camps. Are Modern parents needlessly overprotective, or is the world a more complicated and dangerous place than it was when previous generations were allowed to wander about unsupervised?
From the she s an irresponsible mother camp came: Shame on you for being so careless about his safety, in Comments on the buffongton post. And there was this from a mother of four: How would you have felt if he didn t come home? But Skenazy got a lot of support, too, with women and men writing in with stories about how they were allowed to take trips all by them selves at seven or eight. She also got heaps of praise for bucking the helicopter parent trend: Good for this Mom, one commenter wrote on the buffongton post. This is a much-needed reality check.
Last week, encouraged by all the attention, Skenazy started her own blog Free Range, kids promoting the idea that modern children need some of the same independence that her generation had. In the good old days nine-year-old baby boomers rode their bikes to school, walked to the store, took buses and even subways all by themselves. Her blog, she says, is dedicated to sensible parenting. At Free Range Kids, we believe in safe kids. We believe in car seats and safety belts. We do NOT believe that every time school-age children go outside, they need a security guard.
So why are some parents so nervous about letting their children out of their sight? Are cities and towns less safe and kids more vulnerable to crimes like child kidnap and sexual abuse than they were in previous generations?
Not exactly. New York City, for instance, is safer than it s ever been; it s ranked 36th in crime among all American cities. Nationwide, stringer kidnaps are extremely rare; there s a one-in-a-million chance a child will be taken by a stranger, according to the Justice Department. And 90 percent of sexual abuse cases are committed by someone the child knows. Mortality rates from all causes, including disease and accidents, for American children are lower now than they were 25 years ago. According to Child Trends, a nonprofit research group, between 1980 and 2003 death rates dropped by 44 percent for children aged 5 to 14 and 32 percent for teens aged 15 to 19.
Then there s the whole question of whether modern parents are more watchful and nervous about safety than previous generations. Yes, some are. Part of the problem is that with wall to wall Internet and cable news, every missing child case gets so much airtime that it s not surprising even normal parental anxiety can be amplified. And many middle-class parents have gotten used to managing their children s time and shuttling them to various enriching activities, so the idea of letting them out on their own can seem like a risk. Back in 1972, when many of today s parents were kids, 87 percent of children who lived within a mile of school walked or biked every day. But today, the Centers for Disease Control report that only 13 percent of children bike, walk or otherwise t themselves to school.
The extra supervision is both a city and a suburb phenomenon. Parents are worried about crime, and they are worried about kids getting caught in traffic in a city that s not used to pedestrians. On the other hand, there are still plenty of kids whose parents give them a lot of independence, by choice or by necessity. The After School Alliance finds that more than 14 million kids aged 5 to 17 are responsible for taking care of themselves after school. Only 6.5 million kids participate in organized programs. Many children who have working parents have to take the subway or bus to get to school. Many do this by themselves because they have no other way to get to the schools, says Dr. Richard Gallagher, director of the Parenting Institute at the New York University Child Study Center.
For those parents who wonder how and when they should start allowing their kids more freedom, there s no clear-cut answer. Child experts discourage a one-size-fits-all approach to parenting. What s right for Skenazy s nine-year-old could be inappropriate for another one. It all depends on developmental issue, maturity, and the psychological and emotional makeup of that child. Several factors must be taken into account, says Gallagher. The ability to follow parent guidelines, the child s level of comfort in handling such situations, and a child s general judgment should be weighed.
Gallagher agrees with Skenazy that many nine-year-olds are ready for independence like taking public transportation alone. At certain times of the day, on certain routes, the subways are generally safe for these children, especially if they have grown up in the city and have been taught how to be safe, how to obtain help if they are concerned for their safety, and how to avoid unsafe situations by being watchful and on their toes.
But even with more traffic and fewer sidewalks, modern parents do have one advantage their parents didn t: the cell phone. Being able to check in with a child anytime goes a long way toward relieving parental anxiety and may help parents loosen their control a little sooner. Skenazy got a lot of criticism because she didn t give her kid her cell phone because she thought he d lose it and wanted him to learn to go it alone without depending on mom a major principle of free-range parenting. But most parents are more than happy to use cell phones to keep track of their kids.
And for those who like the idea of free-range kids but still struggle with their inner helicopter parent, there may be a middle way. A new generation of GPS cell phones with tracking software make it easier than ever to follow a child s every movement via the Internet without seeming to interfere or hover. Of course, when they go to college, they might start objecting to being monitored as they re on parole .
1. When Lenore Skenazy s son was allowed to take the subway alone, he ________.
A.was afraid that he might get lost
B.enjoyed having the independence
C.was only too pleased to take the risk
D.thought he was an exceptional child
2. Lenore Skenazy believes that keeping kids under careful watch
A.hinders their healthy growth
B.adds too much to parents expenses
C.shows traditional parental caution
D.bucks the latest parenting trend
3. Skenazy s decision to let her son take the Subway alone has net with________.
A.opposition from her own family
B.share parenting experience
C.fight against child abuse
D.protect children s rights
4. Skenazy started her own blog to ________.
A.promote sensible parenting
B.share parenting experience
C.fight against child abuse
D.protect children s rights
5. According to the author, New York City ________.
A.ranks high in road accidents
B.is much safe than before
C.ranks low in child mortality rates
D.is less dangerous than small cities
6. Parents today are more nervous about their kids safety than previous generations because________.
A.there are now fewer children in the family
B.the number of traffic accidents has been increasing
C.their fear is amplified by media exposure of crime
D.crime rates have been on the rise over the years
7. According to child experts, how and when kids may be allowed more freedom depends on ________.
A.the traditions and customs of the community
B.the safety conditions of their neighborhood
C.their parents psychological makeup
D.their maturity and personal qualities
8. According to Gallagher and Skenazy, children who are watchful will be better able to stay away from Unsafe situations.
9. Being able to find out where a child is anytime helps lessen parents Their anxiety and control.
10. Nowadays with the help of GPS cell phones, parents can, from a distance, track their children s Movements.
1. B) enjoyed having the independence
2. A) hinders their healthy growth
3. D) somewhat mixed responses
4. A) promote sensible promoting
5. B) is much safer than before
6. C) their fear is amplified by media exposure of crime
7. D) their maturity and personal qualities
8.unsafe situation
9.anxiety
10. every moment
下一篇: 英语六级考试阅读理解练习及答案(23)
美文欣赏:值不值得,只有自己能衡量
美国众议院批准政府预算案
In much of Asia, especially the so
河北省邢台一中2016-2017学年高一上学期第三次月考英语试题
国际英语资讯:Trump says hes committed to helping solve Israeli-Palestinian conflict
国内英语资讯:Xi stresses rule of law, cultivating legal talent
辽宁省阜蒙县高级中学2016-2017学年高一上学期期中考试英语试题 Word版无答案
外媒盘点:老外学中文必背的100个汉字
格斗狂人十秒击败太极大师 多位功夫高手向其下战书
米歇尔 奥巴马声称永远不会竞选美国总统
亲诚惠容结善缘,周边外交续新篇
国内英语资讯:Belt and Road Initiative has great global influence: Argentine Ambassador
山东省济宁市汶上一中2016-2017学年高一上学期期中检测 英语 Word版含答案
美国人为了更快地学外语,居然要改造大脑?
假定你是李华, 得知你的英国笔友John获得了在伦敦举行中学生中文演讲比赛一等奖。你为他感到骄傲, 并给他写一封祝贺信
江西省南昌二中2016-2017学年高一上学期第二次月考英语试题 Word版含答案
国内英语资讯:Chinese, U.S. officials discuss all-round economic cooperation over phone
江西省南昌十九中2016-2017学年高一上学期第二次月考(12月)英语试题 Word版含答案
Many people think dreams are full of messages 阅读理解答案
The London Underground (The Tube)阅读理解答案
数钱数到手软!盘点10个和钱有关的英语表达
高中生面临沉重的学习压力,因此,很多同学课间休息时间也坐在教室里学习,但效果并不理想。就此,
觉得自己的工作毫无意义?越来越多人这么想
咖啡英语超级大科普
国内英语资讯:China to send two giant pandas to Denmark
“运动药丸”有望取代健身房
法国总统候选人辩论火爆
江西省赣州市兴国县将军中学2016-2017学年高一上学期第二次月考英语试题 Word版无答案
河南省安阳一中2016-2017学年高一上学期第二次阶段考试英语试题
国际英语资讯:Merkel: G20 to further promote globalization, inclusive growth