Peking University professor Xu Dianqing has apologized to citizens of Shenzhen for his prediction that real estate prices would rise in the past year.
A year ago on July 11, while attending a business forum in the southern Chinese city, he claimed that housing prices there would be higher than a year later. If it turned out to be the opposite, he would take out a one-page ad in a local paper to apologize.
Judging from online surveys, most people did not have much sympathy for him. Rather, the turn of events proved to be another nail in the coffin for the independence of China's pundits.
Business commentators in this country have long been accused of secretly aligning with business interests. They talk up prices, especially housing prices. They talk down to consumers who look up to them for a golden nugget of wisdom in a murky world of instant changes.
A few years ago, a Hong Kong scholar said that there were no more than "five" qualified economists on the mainland. You may dispute the exact number, but it is clear that many, if not most, of our talking heads in professional spheres do not have - or do not cherish - independence.
And I think I know why.
There are so many forces out to corrupt an independent mind it is a wonder we still have a few voices left that are relatively untainted.
By chance, I am something of a film critic on the side. I started by reviewing Hollywood movies and published them on the Internet. For the first two years, I wrote what I wanted.
By the time I arrived in Beijing, I got one-on-one interviews with well-known filmmakers. None of them pressured me to spin for them, but when I started writing I felt I should not say damning things about the works of these people who had granted me the "honor" of an interview or a dinner.
I woke up to the corrosive power of self-censorship. The more opportunities I have to sidle up to powers-that-be, the weaker my position will be as an independent critic.
I also got a taste of regular entertainment reporting: I was invited to a screening, given a red envelope containing a few hundred yuan for "taxi fare", and was expected to turn in a glowing review. When I refused, I was blacklisted. One big production company even suspended an ongoing screening to kick me out of the theater that was showing its latest blockbuster.
My biggest shock came during a so-called forum, taking place after a special screening of a mediocre film. The panel was made up of big names from the establishment, and they outdid one another in extolling the movie. When I used some adjectives to suggest the film's weaknesses, people looked at me as if I were from another planet. I was never invited again.
If people are willing to forsake their impartiality for a few hundred yuan, imagine the allure of 100 times that sum, which business experts may get for such public appearances. If not money, then peer pressure, group conformity, or the urge not to disturb the peace. In the end, what is left is a phalanx of paid publicists who are disguised as third-party commentators.
Industry insiders do not seem to know that independent reviews, including negative ones, are an inseparable part of the healthy growth of their industry. Once you shut off the spigot of outside voices, you are humming with only self-congratulations.
I was shocked at the lack of self-confidence displayed by some of our biggest filmmakers in dealing with people like me. I am not out to wreck their labor of love or massive investment - I do not have that ability, but I do not want to become their mouthpiece either.
英语四级考试仔细阅读每日一练(12.20)
备战龄与智慧-姜真的是老的辣吗?
四级阅读练习:户外广告——广告牌的兴起
英语四级考试仔细阅读每日一练(12.26)
12月英语四级考试阅读部分漫谈
英语四级阅读长难句结构分析及备考方法(一)
备战四级阅读练习:研究显示快乐的人比一般人长寿35%
备战四级阅读练习:TED的绝妙创意——关闭科技
英语四级阅读理解模拟题及答案详解20
四级考前30天阅读冲刺:重真题 找技巧
大学英语四级考试阅读理解练习19篇之语言
四级英语阅读理解三大体裁阅读结构解析
四级阅读练习:我们对垃圾的爱——垃圾成堆
四级六级阅读练习:灰尘背后的那些事儿
英语四级阅读理解模拟题及答案详解23
备战四级阅读练习:面对灾难,人类大脑如何反应
15分钟规定时间内完胜英语四级快速阅读
英语四级考试阅读理解考前温习
四级考试阅读冲刺策略:有效利用真题
英语四六级阅读:从单词到文章能力提高策略
四级考前冲刺 快速四级阅读技巧
英语四级阅读长难句结构分析及备考方法(四)
四级阅读练习:为什么爆料网站离不开专业媒体?
四六级快速阅读技巧
北京:四六级阅读,定位要靠谱
帮你Hold得住四六级仔细阅读
备战四级阅读练习:压力之下表现优异的秘密
白颉:英语四级考试篇章阅读"四原则排除法"
英语四级考试阅读理解考前练习
专家解析大学英语四级考试历年阅读真题(四)
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |