When I answer a reader question over English, I try not to say much. Instead I choose to trust the reader to find out the answers by themselves. This attitude of non-interference, thank you very much, often works.
Here, for example, is a little to-and-fro with Shirlie (who always seems to have another question ready for me the minute I have answered the last one):
Xin: Thanks for writing. Please hit this link (omitted) for reply in detail.
Shirlie: Thank you very much…. But I'm sorry I have to bother you again. This time I'm really confused by some explanation about a 20-minute walk and a 20 minutes' walk. I think they are both right. But some said they are not. Here I copied the original question for you:
3. Every morning Mr. Smith takes a ______ to his office.
A.20 minutes' walk B.20 minute's walk
C.20-minutes walk D.20-minute walk
The answer is A. But others say the answer is D. I think both are right. Some said they chose D because A needn't an article. Is that right? I don't think they are right. What's your opinion?
Xin: Never mind my opinion (it's not a matter of opinion, is it?), the answer is D. Have a good day.
Shirlie: Thanks, but I'm still wondering why A is not right? Even some books say "a 20 minutes' walk" is right.
Xin: May I challenge you to produce the book?
Shirlie: Thank you for your patience. I'm the last one who wants you to be bothered by silly grammatical questions, which drive me crazy sometimes and I'm trying to escape from them. I'm sorry I can not present you the book because the book is not available now, but the website is available. You would say it's stupid to believe in the websites, yap, sometimes it is true. The book won't be available until next week when I go home. So I will make everything clear at that time. The website is here (omitted).
Xin: I'll skip the website in anticipation of the book. Yes, I "would say it's stupid to believe in websites", but I wouldn't say "yap".
These days, one can't even believe in books (which is why I asked you to kindly produce it in the first place), not to mention websites.
Shirlie: I returned home and found out what the book told their readers is: 20 minutes' walk; a 20-minute walk; they are both right. Sorry to have bothered you because of my poor memory.
Xin: Now that you've produced the book, you may look at it this way: If "a 20 minutes' walk" is as good as "a 20-minute walk", "20-minute" as adjective would not have been invented.
To cure from this book, read other books.
Shirlie: Haa, to look at a thing in a different way can be so interesting. Your suggestion is good and I will try it with other problems. Still I have a question: Can "still" modify "others"? Like in this sentence: There are some robots working in factories, others working in the hospitals, ____ (still others/ the others) working in the schools.
Xin: "Still I have a question", as though I didn't know... Now, can "still" modify "others"? Apparently yes. Here, "still" is not a modifier, though. It's an adverb.
An easy example: Some readers ask questions. Others don't. Some ask one question and leave me alone. Some others ask two or more questions but all of them at once. Still others, such as Shirlie, prefer to ask one question after another.
In fact, I'm sure Shirlie has still another one up her sleeve right now, ready to release the moment she reads this.
Got to run...
2016届高考英语二轮复习专项训练:非选择题专练卷(2)
2016届高考英语二轮复习精品资料(高考押题):专题15 完形填空(原卷版)
2016届高考英语二轮复习专项训练:选择题专练卷(6)
2016届高三英语二轮复习课件:专题1 语法 板块2 第3讲 情态动词和虚拟语气
2016届高三英语二轮复习课件:专题2 完形填空
2016届高考英语二轮复习专项训练:选择题专练卷(2)
2016届高三英语二轮复习课件:专题1 语法 板块3 第1讲 三大从句
2016届高考英语二轮复习精品资料(高考押题):专题15 完形填空(解析版)
2016届高考英语二轮复习专项训练:专题限时检测(2)形容词、副词和介词(短语)
2016届高考英语二轮复习精品资料(高考押题):专题12 特殊句式(解析版)
2016届高考英语二轮复习精品资料(高考押题):专题14 阅读理解(解析版)
(二模前)2016届高考英语二轮复习词汇综合练:11(解析版)
2016届高考英语二轮复习专项训练:选择题专练卷(5)
2016届高考英语二轮复习专项训练:任务型阅读与书面表达组合卷(2)
(二模前)2016届高考英语二轮复习词汇综合练:12(解析版)
2016届高三英语二轮复习课件:专题1 语法 板块1 第1讲 名词、冠词和代词
2016届高三英语二轮复习课件:专题5 书面表达 第1节 第2讲 如何写记叙文的摘要
2016届高考英语二轮复习专项训练:非选择题专练卷(4)
2016届高考英语二轮复习精讲学案:专题03 形容词和副词(原卷版)
2016届高考英语二轮复习精讲学案:专题02 代词(原卷版)
2016届高考英语二轮复习精品资料(高考押题):专题11 定语从句(原卷版)
2016届高考英语二轮复习专项训练:任务型阅读与书面表达组合卷(4)
2016届高考英语二轮复习精品资料(高考押题):专题16 书面表达(解析版)
2016届高考英语二轮复习精讲学案:专题04 动词及动词短语(原卷版)
2016届高考英语二轮复习专项训练:选择题专练卷(3)
2016届高考英语二轮复习精品资料(高考押题):专题14 阅读理解(原卷版)
2016届高考英语二轮复习精讲学案:专题05 介词与介词短语(原卷版)
2016届高考英语二轮复习精品资料(高考押题):专题13 情景交际(解析版)
2016届高三英语二轮复习课件:专题4 任务型阅读
2016届高考英语二轮复习精品资料(高考押题):专题16 书面表达(原卷版)
| 不限 |
| 英语教案 |
| 英语课件 |
| 英语试题 |
| 不限 |
| 不限 |
| 上册 |
| 下册 |
| 不限 |