Shirlie writes:
I like your explanation in your column titled "Safe or Safety". I think your idea is clear and easy to understand. I agree with you on the "bizarre" things, which often happen to me when I teach.
I am an English teacher at a middle school. I try my hard to avoid the "bizarre" things but just find it unavoidable. It happens everywhere, in the text book, in everyday test paper, and I often get confused by some multiple-choice questions. For example, one question is like this: You don't look ____. You'd better go to see a doctor. A wonderfully B well C nice D good.
The preferred answer is B (well). So, how can I explain to my students they should choose B but not D?
In my experience, when someone really doesn't feel good, the native speaker likes to say: Are you ok? or Are you alright? or Do you feel good? or in some other ways. Thank you very much for your help.
My comments:
When people say you look good, they mean you look pretty and smart - they are not talking about your physical wellbeing, or the lacks thereof. When they say you don't look well, they mean you look ill (and you'd better go and see a doctor).
If you ask the native speaker why this is so, they'll probably say that it's just the way it is, that they've grown up saying so without having given it much thought one way or the other.
Grammar, you see, is a series of agreements (over how to string words together) put in place to avoid misunderstanding. It's developed through experiment, over time and by trial and error. But grammar rules are not as strict as, say traffic regulations and criminal laws. That's why, if someone misspeaks, no-one will call the police. Language usages are more of a habitual and customary nature (as they are to the native speaker) than one about logic and reason. That's why grammar of one language often appears illogical and irreconcilable to foreigners, who've been used only to the equally peculiar and idiosyncratic tongue of their own.
In the process of learning a language, people put little store by grammar rules, especially in the beginning. Children, you see, learn to speak by imitating parents, fellow pupils and others rather than by memorizing grammatical rules and regulations. To my knowledge, no children, however prodigious, have learned a language, native or foreign, by doing multiple-choice tests alone, which seems to be a prevalent practice in Chinese schools.
The fact that English for the Chinese is a foreign language is often taken as a good excuse for failure, but it's a poor excuse. All excuses are in fact bad excuses. Good excuses are even worse. A foreign language is still a language, isn't it?
This foreign language thing is overblown and exaggerated in China. There's too much fear of it in here, it seems. People are not taking it easy, one step a time. Children are not given enough opportunities to speak and be familiar with the language before they are being tested about it.
If you recall our modern history, you'll perhaps realize that it took some time for us to come to terms with foreigners as different groups. In the beginning, all Westerners, whether they are German, English, French or Russian, are called foreign devils because at the first glances they looked the same to the Chinese eye. They were all red-faced, blue-eyed and with a big nose and were generally up to no good (considering what they were here for in the very beginning).
The Big Noses didn't quite look human (the way one of us looked human). Only when we got to know them well (not good) enough do they begin to appear human, each with their individual nationalities, personalities and so forth. But in the beginning, before we got to understand the finer details about each and everyone of them, they all looked odd and the same - it just didn't make sense.
It's the same way with English as a foreign language. It is only when one gets fairly acquainted with the nitty-gritty do they begin to find it reasonable (in its own way) and, in fact, interesting.
I can't tell you, Shirlie, how you may explain to your student why when people don't look WELL they need to see a doctor, but if I were you, I'd encourage them to keep listening (to native speakers preferably, via videos and tapes in case a real Big Nose is hard to come by) and to keep speaking. If mistakes are made, so what, just do it again.
I can imagine that somewhere along the line you'll tell them "never mind reasons, it's the way it is" or, as any mother will say to a child, "you'll understand when you grow up." You may sound a bit mystical that way but I think you can get away with it to some extent.
So long as you keep encouraging them to listen and to speak and see to it that they do. That way, eventually, they'll all look good.
And they'll make you, Shirlie, look good too.
时事资讯:法第一夫人献声曼德拉生日音乐会
时事资讯:六成美国人支持二战时向日本投原子弹
时事资讯:奥巴马:美中将"塑造21世纪"
时事资讯:中国网民人数达到3.38亿
时事资讯:比亚迪敦促政府为环保汽车提供补贴
时事资讯:美国新泽西州三市长涉嫌腐败被捕
美国智库称中国在华阳礁建雷达塔
时事资讯:G8领导人穿上明星大衣 参加峰会不惧风暴
时事资讯:意总理女儿公开指责老爸与女模曝绯闻
特朗普轻松赢得内华达州初选
时事资讯:印度拒绝美国减排呼吁
澳大利亚大幅增加国防开支
时事资讯:一条小鱼可以拯救你的听力?
时事资讯:制造业好转显示全球经济开始复苏
时事资讯:俄士兵配给新变化:糖果换香烟
时事资讯:美国经济回升缓慢导致美元下跌
时事资讯:巧克力曲奇女王的创业故事
时事资讯:韩国指责朝鲜发动网络攻击
沙特表示 石油减产不会发生
时事资讯:社交网站好友申请爆棚 盖茨无奈退出
时事资讯:奥巴马获赠巴西队球衣 面露尴尬
时事资讯:阿里巴巴在美启动广告宣传
奥巴马要求国会同意关闭关塔那摩监狱
时事资讯:发手机短信会让孩子变笨?
中国将派军舰参加在美国夏威夷举行的环太军演
时事资讯:中国率先购买500亿美元IMF债券
时事资讯:意总理"有染"应召女郎获盛邀出席巴黎派对
G20将邀请穷国参与国际税务谈判
时事资讯:奥巴马选大使唯"钱"是举?
时事资讯:"老妈裤"时尚风波 奥巴马笑称自己老土
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |