Governments must ensure that their major cities receive the financial support they need in order to thrive, because it is primarily in cities that a nations cultural traditions are preserved and generated.
The speakers claim is actually threefold: ensuring the survival of large cities and, in turn, that of cultural traditions, is a proper function of government; government support is needed for our large dries and cultural traditions to survive and thrive; and cultural traditions are preserved and generated primarily in our large cities. I strongly disagree with all three claims.
First of all, subsidizing cultural traditions is not a proper role of govemment. Admittedly, certain objectives, such as public health and safety, are so essential to the survival of large dries and of nations that government has a duty to ensure that they are met. However, these objectives should not extend tenuously to preserving cultural traditions. Moreover, government cannot possibly play an evenhanded role as cultural patron. Inadequate resources call for restrictions, priorities, and choices. It is unconscionable to relegate normative decisions as to which cities or cultural traditions are more deserving, valuable, or needy to a few legislators, whose notions about culture might be misguided or unrepresentative of those of the general populace. Also, legislators are all too likely to make choices in favor of the cultural agendas of their home towns and states, or of lobbyists with the most money and influence.
Secondly, subsidizing cultural traditions is not a necessary role of government. A lack of private funding might justify an exception. However, culture--by which I chiefly mean the fine
arts--has always depended primarily on the patronage of private individuals and businesses, and not on the government. The Medicis, a powerful banking family of Renaissance Italy, supported artists Michelangelo and Raphael. During the 20th Century the primary source of cultural support were private foundations established by industrial magnates Carnegie, Mellon, Rockefeller and Getty. And tomorrow cultural support will come from our new technology and media moguls----including the likes of Ted Turner and Bill Gates. In short, philanthropy is alive and well today, and so government need not intervene to ensure that our cultural traditions are preserved and promoted.
Finally, and perhaps most importantly, the speaker unfairly suggests that large cities serve as the primary breeding ground and sanctuaries for a nations cultural traditions. Today a nations distinct cultural traditions--its folk art, crafts, traditional songs, customs and ceremonies--burgeon instead in small towns and rural regions. Admittedly, our cities do serve as our centers for high art; big cities are where we deposit, display, and boast the worlds preeminent art, architecture, and music. But big-city culture has little to do any- more with one nations distinct cultural traditions. After all, modern cities are essentially multicultural stew pots; accordingly, by assisting large cities a government is actually helping to create a global culture as well to subsidize the traditions of other nations cultures.
In the final analysis, government cannot philosophically justify assisting large cities for the purpose of either promoting or preserving the nations cultural traditions; nor is government assistance necessary toward these ends. Moreover, assisting large cities would have little bearing on our distinct cultural traditions, which abide elsewhere.
七岁孩子QQ立志"上清华北大" 家长忧:变世故了?
小区游戏机扎堆 专家吁净化儿童成长环境
“放学不许背书包”引争议 政策频出成效如何?
北京教委回应“上传学生信息至客户端”
调查显示:六成家长反对用iPad写作业
时评:儿童沉迷游戏机绝非“儿戏”
幼升小不可不知的13个关键词:就近入学·划片
幼儿学英语培训班风行 专家:不主张过早上
家长分享:2014年幼升小后悔择校私立学校北外附
幼升小不可不知的13个关键词:寄宿
2015幼升小择校前必知四大法则
“十一”也是亲子沟通“黄金周”
北京市中小学提前制定课间安全措施
幼升小不可不知的13个关键词:面试
北京八大城区2015幼升小择校推荐
北京部分小学2014年幼升小入学条件政策放宽
幼升小不可不知的13个关键词:户口年限
幼升小不可不知的13个关键词:学籍
幼升小不可不知的13个关键词:实际居住地
家长必读:西城区2015幼升小政策6大改动
2015幼升小参考:2014海淀区放宽暂住证时间限制
幼升小不可不知的13个关键词:借读
幼升小不可不知的13个关键词:幼升小
安全教育是校园惨案最好的“保险”
一年级新生状况百出 教师直呼“上班需要勇气”
幼升小不可不知的13个关键词:幼小衔接
幼儿园孩子被禁食,你还敢跟老师争吵吗?
孩子出生晚几天就要多读一年书 陕西家长留言获回应
老师批改作业用T取代X 你怎么看?
2014西城区商用房不能作为2015年幼升小入学依据
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |