GRE北美范文对备考GRE写作有一定的指导作用,下面为大家整理了最完整版的GRE北美范文,主要是关于GRE ISSUE作文范文,供大家应用。
There are two types of laws: just and unjust. Every individual in a society has a responsibility to obey just laws and, even more importantly, to disobey and resist unjust laws.
According to this statement, each person has a duty to not only obey just laws but also disobey unjust ones. In my view this statement is too extreme, in two respects. First, it wrongly categorizes any law as either just or unjust; and secondly, it recommends an ineffective and potentially harmful means of legal reform.
First, whether a law is just or unjust is rarely a straightforward issue. The fairness of any law depends on ones personal value system. This is especially true when it comes to personal freedoms. Consider, for example, the controversial issue of abortion. Individuals with particular religious beliefs tend to view laws allowing mothers an abortion choice as unjust, while individuals with other value systems might view such laws as just.
The fairness of a law also depends on ones personal interest, or stake, in the legal issue at hand. After all, in a democratic society the chief function of laws is to strike a balance among competing interests. Consider, for example, a law that regulates the toxic effluents a certain factory can emit into a nearby river. Such laws are designed chiefly to protect public health. But complying with the regulation might be costly for the company; the factory might be forced to lay off employees or shut down altogether, or increase the price of its products to compensate for the cost of compliance. At stake are the respective interests of the companys owners, employees, and customers, as well as the opposing interests of the regions residents whose health and safety are impacted. In short, the fairness of the law is subjective, depending largely on how ones personal interests are affected by it.
The second fundamental problem with the statement is that disobeying unjust laws often has the opposite affect of what was intended or hoped for. Most anyone would argue, for instance, that our federal system of income taxation is unfair in one respect or another. Yet the end result of widespread disobedience, in this case tax evasion, is to perpetuate the system. Free-riders only compel the government to maintain tax rates at high levels in order to ensure adequate revenue for the various programs in its budget.
Yet another fundamental problem with the statement is that by justifying a violation of one sort of law we find ourselves on a slippery slope toward sanctioning all types of illegal behavior, including egregious criminal conduct. Returning to the abortion example mentioned above, a person strongly opposed to the freedom-of-choice position might maintain that the illegal blocking of access to an abortion clinic amounts to justifiable disobedience. However, it is a precariously short leap from this sort of civil disobedience to physical confrontations with clinic workers, then to the infliction of property damage, then to the bombing of the clinic and potential murder.
In sum, because the inherent function of our laws is to balance competing interests, reasonable people with different priorities will always disagree about the fairness of specific laws. Accordingly, radical action such as resistance or disobedience is rarely justified merely by ones subjective viewpoint or personal interests. And in any event, disobedience is never justifiable when the legal rights or safety of innocent people are jeopardized as a result.
2009最新中考英语单项填空模拟考试卷 附详解答案
“爱”成中学生作文出现频率最高词汇
2010年中考英语词汇旧词新义:cost
2009中考英语词汇表 系列O
为英语写作”画龙点睛“的24句谚语
常用英语词语辨析105组(5)
2009中考英语词汇表 系列S
2009中考英语词汇表 系列N
2009中考英语词汇表 系列YXZ
词汇笔记 五种词汇的学习方法 超强
2010年中考英语词汇熟词新义:start
初中英语常用词组复习1
2009中考英语词汇短语集锦 (2)
2009中考英语词汇表 系列JKL
2010年中考英语词汇旧词新义:clean
从奥巴马演讲词看英语写作词汇的应用
2010年中考英语词汇旧词新义:deal
初中英语常用词组复习2
2009中考英语词汇表 系列I
中考英语词汇“for短语”全攻略
09年中考英语总复习经典习题讲解2一名词
09年中考英语总复习经典习题讲解4一数词
09年中考英语总复习经典习题讲解3一冠词
2009中考英语词汇表 系列PQ
09年中考英语总复习经典习题讲解1一冠词
张惠妹《排山倒海》英文版
2009中考英语词汇表 系列M
英乐时空Here I Am
2010年中考英语词汇旧词新义:cause
初中英语常用词组1 动词词组
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |