It is the artist, not the critic, who gives society something of lasting value.
This statement asserts that art, not the art critic, provides something of lasting value to society. I strongly agree with the statement. Although the critic can help us understand and appreciate art, more often than not, critique is either counterproductive to achieving the objective of art or altogether irrelevant to that objective.
To support the statement the speaker might point out the three ostensible functions of the art critic. First, critics can help us understand and interpret art; a critic who is familiar with a particular artist and his or her works might have certain insights about those works that the layperson would not. Secondly, a critics evaluation of an art work serves as a filter, which helps us determine which art is worth our time and attention. For example, a new novel by a best-selling author might nevertheless be an uninspired effort, and if the critic can call our attention to this fact we gain time to seek out more worthwhile literature to read. Thirdly, a critic can provide feedback for artists; and constructive criticism, if taken to heart, can result in better work.
However, reflecting on these three functions makes clear that the art critic actually offers very little to society.
The first function is better accomplished by docents and teachers, who are more able to enhance a laypersons appreciation and understanding of art by providing an objective, educated interpretation of it. Besides, true appreciation of art occurs at the moment we encounter art; it is the emotional, even visceral impact that art has on our senses, spirits, and souls that is the real value of art. A critic can actually provide a disservice by distracting us from that experience.
The critics second function that of evaluator who filters out bad art from the worthwhile is one that we must be very wary of. History supports this caution. In the role of judge, critics have failed us repeatedly. Consider, for example, Voltaires rejection of Shakespeare as barbaric because he did not conform to neo-classical principles of unity. Or, consider the complete dismissal of Beethovens music by the esteemed critics of his time. The art critics judgment is limited by the narrow confines of old and established parameters for evaluation. Moreover, critical judgment is often misguided by the ego; thus its value is questionable in any event.
I turn finally to the critics third function: to provide useful feedback to artists. The value of this function is especially suspect. Any artist, or anyone who has studied art, would agree that true art is the product of the artists authentic passion, a manifestation of the artists unique creative impulse, and a creation of the artists spirit. If art were shaped by the concern for integrating feedback from all criticism, it would become a viable craft, but at the same time would cease to be art.
In sum, none of the ostensible functions of the critic are of much value at all, let alone of lasting value, to society. On the other hand, the artist, through works of art, provides an invaluable and unique mirror of the culture of the time during which the work was produced a mirror for the artists contemporaries and for future generations to gaze into for insight and appreciation of history. The art critic in a subordinate role, more often than not, does a disservice to society by obscuring this mirror.
2017届浙江省常山县高考英语一轮复习阅读理解专练:4(含答案)
国内英语资讯: China punishes firms for faking assets to get listed
2017届四川省内江市隆昌县高考英语一轮复习完形填空专练:8(含解析)
体坛英语资讯:Lin Dan and Lee Chong Wei on track to final showdown
2017“两高”工作报告要点双语对照
2017届四川省内江市隆昌县高考英语一轮复习完形填空专练:1(含解析)
悲剧or喜剧?遥控器决定剧情走向
第一天上课坐前排就是学霸吗?
体坛英语资讯:Bayern enlarge advantage atop the standings in German Bundesliga
体坛英语资讯:Guardiola wins Manager of the Month award
中国对川普商标申请的处理引发伦理担忧
2017届浙江省常山县高考英语一轮复习阅读理解专练:7(含答案)
失眠这个问题有多严重?它和熬夜可不一样!
表面之下 Under the Surface
国际英语资讯:Iraqi forces push deeper in city center of western Mosul
2017届四川省内江市隆昌县高考英语一轮复习完形填空专练:9(含解析)
体坛英语资讯:Balotelli on target, Nice slip up points in Ligue 1 title race
【南方新课堂】2017高考英语二轮复习专题训练:组合练 3语法填空+短文改错+书面表达(含解析)
性隐喻惹风波 沃伦•巴菲特这样解读投资
2017届浙江省常山县高考英语一轮复习阅读理解专练:8(含答案)
2017届浙江省常山县高考英语一轮复习阅读理解专练:5(含答案)
【南方新课堂】2017高考英语二轮复习专题训练:专题6 书面表达(含答案)
【南方新课堂】2017高考英语二轮复习专题训练:组合练 4语法填空+短文改错+书面表达(含解析)
体坛英语资讯:Bremen hold Leverkusen 1-1 in German Bundesliga
2017届四川省内江市隆昌县高考英语一轮复习完形填空专练:4(含解析)
亿万富翁的心态是怎样的?
2017届四川省内江市隆昌县高考英语一轮复习完形填空专练:6(含解析)
国际英语资讯:News Analysis: Mainstream left risks losing biggest in upcoming Dutch election
国际英语资讯:Spotlight: South Koreans celebrate Parks ouster in last, festive candlelight rally
2017届浙江省常山县高考英语一轮复习阅读理解专练:12(含答案)
不限 |
英语教案 |
英语课件 |
英语试题 |
不限 |
不限 |
上册 |
下册 |
不限 |