Some of the most powerful people in the world have felt compelled to act against this threat. President Clinton swiftly imposed a ban on federal funding for human-cloning research. Bills were put in the works in both houses of Congress to outlaw human cloning because it was deemed as a fundamentally evil thing that must be stopped. But what, exactly, is bad about it? From an ethical point of view, it is difficult to see exactly what is wrong with cloning human beings. The people who are afraid of cloning tend to assume that someone would, for example, break into Napoleons Tomb, steal some DNA and make a bunch of emperors. In reality, infertile people who use donated sperm, eggs, or embryos would probably use cloning. Do the potential harms outweigh the benefits of cloning? From what we know now, they dont. Therefore, we should not rush placing a ban on a potentially useful method of helping infertile, genetically at-risk, homosexual, or single people to become parents.
Do human beings have a right to reproduce? No one has the moral right to tell another person that they should not be able to have children, and I dont see why Bill Clinton has that right either. If humans have a right to reproduce, what right does society have to limit the means? Essentially all reproduction done these days is with medical help at delivery, and even before. Truly natural human reproduction would make pregnancy-related death the number one killer of adult women.
Some forms of medical help are more invasive than others. With in-vitro fertilization, the sperm and egg are combined in a lab and surgically implanted in the womb. Less than two decades ago, a similar concern was raised over the ethical issues involving test-tube babies. Today, nearly 30,000 such babies have been born in the United States alone. This miracle has made many parents happy. So what principle says that one combination of genetic material in a flask is acceptable, but not another?
Nature clones people all the time. Approximately one in 1000 births is an identical twin. However, despite how many or how few individual characteristics twins have in common, they are still different people. They have their own identities, their own thoughts, and their own rights. They enter different occupations, get different diseases, and have different experiences with marriage, alcohol, community leadership, etc. Twins have different personalities as would cloned individuals. Even if someone cloned several Napoleons, each would be different and even more unique than twins; the cloned child would be raised in a different setting. Therefore, cloning does not rob individuals of their personality.
Perhaps the strongest ethical argument against cloning is that it could lead to a new, unfamiliar type of family relationship. We have no idea what it would be like to grow up as the child of parents who seem to know you from the inside. Some psychological characteristics may be biologically, or genetically, based. The parent would know in advance what crises a cloned teenager could go through and how he or she will respond. Because the parents may understand what the child is going through, to greater degree than most parents, it may produce a good and loving relationship in the long run. On the other hand, most children want to have their own space. Simply because a family relationship is new and untried is no reason to automatically condemn it. In the past, many types of family relationships were considered harmful, but later showed to cause no harm to the children. Among these is joint custody after divorce, gay and lesbian parenting, and interracial adoption. As with adoption, in-vitro fertilization, and the use of donor sperm, how the child will react to the news about his or her arrival in this world will depend on how the parents feel about their mode of reproduction. Parents and children may adjust to cloning far more easily than we might think, just as it happened with in-vitro fertilization.
One recurring image in anti-cloning propaganda is of some evil dictator raising an army of cloned warriors. But who is going to raise such an army. Clones start out life as babies. It is much easier to recruit young adults than to take care of babies for twenty years. Remember that cloning isnt the same as genetic engineering. No one can make another superman and his super powers might have a slim chance of being genetically determined, but nothing is certain.
Some might think that cloning is playing God. However, can you really say that you know Gods intentions? There is substantial disagreement as to what Gods will is. Armstrong wrote, anyone who has truly proved that God exists, that God isnt only Creator, but Life-giver, Designer, Sustainer, and Ruler over all his creation, knows that the human family began with one man, and that together with him a wife, miraculously created from his own body and as unique and original a creation as Adam himself, formed the first family. Though Gods miraculous creation of Eve was far from cloning, it is interesting to note in passing that Gods own Word says He used Adams rib-physical bone and tissue - to create Eve?
Another argument against cloning is that it would only be available to the wealthy and, therefore, would increase social inequality. What else is new? This is the story of American health care. We need a better health care system, not a ban on new technologies. Hopefully our new president will help us with this problem as well.
The U.S. Federal Government should not deem human cloning and cloning research illegal. It may provide a way for completely sterile or homosexual individuals to reproduce, and will probably provide valuable basic research and possible spin-off technologies related to reproduction and development. Our society has respected general rights to control ones body regarding reproduction, and finally prohibiting it would violate the fundamental freedom of scientific inquiring.
Will human cloning be done? Undoubtedly. The technique used in sheep cloning does not require a highly sophisticated laboratory. Since the United States government does not support research on human cloning, and the United Kingdom, France, and Germany have banned it, the research making cloning possible may take place in Asia, Eastern Europe, or the East. Much cloning may also take place in secret, and will occur regardless of United States policies. Approximately eighty percent of Americans feel that cloning is wrong. However, the vast majority of people, including those who rail against cloning research, owe their lives to previous medical discoveries. Dont let the forces of ignorance and fear turn us away from new types of research.
上一篇: 六级冲刺备考阅读练习7
下一篇: 六级冲刺备考阅读练习11
体坛英语资讯:Guangdong win first WCBA crown by beating Bayi 3-2
外国男子手持牛油果抢银行竟得逞两次!
体坛英语资讯:Hungarian runners win the 12th Lake Balaton Supermarathon in Western Hungary
体坛英语资讯:Spain start Euro qualifying with 2-1 win over Norway
国际英语资讯:Interview: American farmer expects U.S., China to ink trade deal before planting season
国际英语资讯:U.S. envoy says Washington seeks new deal with Tehran
研究显示 25岁和55岁最具创新力
国内英语资讯:Construction of 2,240-MW hydropower station underway in upper Yangtze
体坛英语资讯:Boe sweeps mens globes in biathlon World Cup
国际英语资讯:Russia urges U.S. to stop interfering in Venezuela
体坛英语资讯:Chinas Sun Wei wins silver at Birmingham gymnastics World Cup
国际英语资讯:Year of tourism for China, Pacific island countries launched to promote cultural, personnel
报告指出 短视频推动互联网增长
国内英语资讯:Beijing sets up investment fund for its sub-center
国内英语资讯:China ready to play bigger role in promoting peacekeeping operations: Chinese Lt. Gen.
国际英语资讯:Zelensky, Poroshenko advance to second round of Ukraines presidential election: exit poll
国际英语资讯:Venezuelas Supreme Court seeks to strip Guaido of parliamentary immunity
哪些瓜果的皮能吃,但没人知道?
国内英语资讯:China, New Zealand agree to deepen comprehensive strategic partnership
1个月不吃甜食会怎样?竟然性情大变
My Secret 我的秘密
国际英语资讯:Worlds largest industrial show opens in Hanover
国内英语资讯:Economic Watch: Robust factory, service activities show stable economic fundamentals
国际英语资讯:Chinese delegation follows up on Lebanons new conservatory
体坛英语资讯:Renewed Germany grab late win against Netherlands in Amsterdam
国内英语资讯:Central Chinas Wuhan to run for intl wetland city
求职者看过来!破解最常见的五个面试问题
国内英语资讯:Chinas top 10 archaeological finds of 2018
国内英语资讯:2019 China-New Zealand Year of Tourism kicks off
国内英语资讯:China, Cambodia vow to strengthen law enforcement, security cooperation