Supporters of the biotech industry have accused an American scientist of misconduct after she testified to the New Zealand government that a genetically modified bacterium could cause serious damage if released.
The New Zealand Life Sciences Network, an association of pro-GM scientists and organizations, says the view expressed by Elaine Ingham, a soil biologist at Oregon State University in Corvallis, was exaggerated and irresponsible. It has asked her university to discipline her.
But Ingham stands by her comments and says the complaints are an attempt to silence her. Theyre trying to cause trouble with my university and get me fired, Ingham told New Scientist.
The controversy began on 1 February, when Ingham testified before New Zealands Royal Commission on Genetic Modification, which will determine how to regulate GM organisms. Ingham claimed that a GM version of a common soil bacterium could spread and destroy plants if released into the wild. Other researchers had previously modified the bacterium to produce alcohol from organic waste. But Ingham says that when she put it in soil with wheat plants, all of the plants died within a week..
We would lose terrestrialplants... this is an organism that is potentially deadly to the continued survival of human beings, she told the commission. She added that the U. S. Environmental Protection Agency canceled its approval for field tests using the organism once she had told them about her research in 1999.
But last week the New Zealand Life Sciences Network accused Ingham of presenting inaccurate, careless and exaggerated information and generating speculative doomsday scenarios that are not scientifically supportable . They say that her study doesnt even show that the bacteria would survive in the wild, much less kill massive numbers of plants. Whats more, the network says that contrary to Inghams claims, the EPA. was never asked to consider the organism for field trials.
The EPA has not commented on the dispute. But an e-mail to the network from Janet Anderson, director of the EPAs bio pesticides division, says there is no record of a review and/or clearance to field test .
Ingham says EPA officials had told her that the organism was approved for field tests, but says she has few details. Its also not clear whether the organism, first engineered by a German institute for biotechnology, is still in use.
Whether Ingham is right or wrong, her supporters say opponents are trying unfairly to silence her.
I think her concerns should be taken seriously. She shouldnt be harassed in this way, says Ann Clarke, a plant biologist at the University of Guelph in Canada who also testified before the commission. Its an attempt to silence the opposition.
57. The passage centers on the controversy ______.
A) between American and New Zealand biologists over genetic modification
B) as to whether the study of genetic modification should be continued
C) over the possible adverse effect of a GM bacterium on plants
D) about whether Elaine Ingham should be fired by her university
58. Ingham insists that her testimony is based on ______.
A) evidence provided by the EPA of the United States B) the results of an experiment she conducted herself
C) evidence from her collaborative research with German biologists D) the results of extensive field tests in Corvallis, Oregon
59. According to Janet Anderson, the EPA ______.
A) has canceled its approval for field tests of the GM organism B) hasnt reviewed the timings of Inghams research
C) has approved field tests using the GM organism D) hasnt given permission to field test the GM organism
60. According to Ann Clarke, the New Zealand Life Sciences Network ______.
A) should gather evidence to discredit Inghams claims B) should require that the research by their biologists be regulated
C) shouldnt demand that Ingham be disciplined for voicing her views D) shouldnt appease the opposition in such a quiet way
61. Which of the following statements about Ingham is TRUE?
A) Her testimony hasnt been supported by the EPA. B) Her credibility as a scientist hasnt been undermined.
C) She is firmly supported by her university. D) She has made great contributions to the study of GM bacteria.
答案:CBDCA
上一篇: 原始人类足迹的逐渐消失
下一篇: 消费者如何刺激疲软的就业和房地产市场
国内英语资讯:Chinas 1st batch of coronavirus medical supplies arrives in Iran: ambassador
国际英语资讯:Costa Rican prosecutors order raids of presidents offices for data privacy investigation
体坛英语资讯:World champion Xu Jiayu expects tough battle in FINA Champion Swim Series
体坛英语资讯:CLS side Chongqing sign Brazilian forward Marcelo Cirino
十块钱而已 被追了一个星期 又惊又暖!
国内英语资讯:Chinese, Chilean presidents discuss COVID-19 epidemic, bilateral ties over phone
国际英语资讯:China committed to international cooperation against coronavirus: diplomat
国际英语资讯:U.S., coalition forces to withdraw from Afghanistan in 14 months: joint declaration
国际英语资讯:Trump says Pompeo to attend signing of U.S.-Taliban deal
国内英语资讯:Xi Focus: Xis article on improving epidemic prevention and control to be published
疫情当前,中国的这波操作被CNN盯上了……
体坛英语资讯:Preview: Setien debut, Real Madrid vs Sevilla highlight in Spain this weekend
国际英语资讯:COVID-19 cases in Germany rises, intl travel trade fair canceled
Confidence 自信
新西兰航空研发经济舱“卧铺” 再也不用羡慕头等舱了
国内英语资讯:China striving to meet medical needs of non-coronavirus patients in epicenter
体坛英语资讯:Xavi explains reasons for turning down Barca job
国内英语资讯:Over 1,000 patients discharged from Wuhans largest temporary hospital
云健身、云泡吧:疫情下的中国人万事皆可“云”
不接种疫苗已成美国社会主流
NASA公布的南极最新照片,在以肉眼可见的速度融化
娱乐英语资讯:Intl charity concert held in London to support Chinas fight against COVID-19
国际英语资讯:Broader military escalation devastating for civilians in NW Syria: UN political affairs chie
体坛英语资讯:Determined Klinsmann facing his dark past
体坛英语资讯:Young joins Inter Milan
国际英语资讯:First U.S. coronavirus death confirmed in Washington state
国内英语资讯:Hubei receives over 1.86 billion USD of donations amid epidemic
国内英语资讯:Chinese premier urges breakthroughs in medical science to fight epidemic
表示流行病的pandemic和epidemic有什么区别?
体坛英语资讯:Chinese athletes find hidden treasure in mixed doubles curling competitions at winter YOG