Can deceptionpretending that something is true when it is notsometimes have good results?
SAT Essay
Think carefully about the issue presented in the following excerpt and the assignment below.
There are two kinds of pretending. There is the bad kind, as when a person falsely promises to be your friend. But there is also a good kind, where the pretense eventually turns into the real thing. For example, when you are not feeling particularly friendly, the best thing you can do, very often, is to act in a friendly manner. In a few minutes, you may really be feeling friendlier.
Adapted from a book by C. S. Lewis
Assignment:
Can deceptionpretending that something is true when it is notsometimes have good results? Plan and write an essay in which you develop your point of view on this issue. Support your position with reasoning and examples taken from your reading, studies, experience, or observations.
Deception is not necessarily lying and dishonest behaviors that are desinged for sheer personal gain and embeded with malicious motives. In fact, deception is justified in some apt situations.
In the Mahabharata, the greatest ancient war of India, the righteous Pandavas were at war with their evil cousins, the Kauravas. It seemed unlikely that good would win over evil this time; the Kauravas were employing unfair advantages to the maximum. They werent playing fair they had a much larger and stronger army than the Pandavas, possessed weapons of greater strength, and had ferocious demons and giants at their command. They were evil to the extent of slaying helpless soldiers during the battle rest-time at night. In short, if things continued as they were, the Pandavas would be doomed. Unless they played fire with fire, they would lose the war. Bheeshmapitama, the strongest and most skilled among the Kauravas warriors, posed the biggest threat to the Pandavas.
So they came up with a cunning strategy. They killed an elephant having the same name as Bheeshmapitamas son and then sent a messenger to inform him about his sons death. When he got the message, Bheeshmapitama grew suspicious since his son was a formidable warrior. The others assured him that the message was a ploy to weaken him emotionally; however, Bheeshmapitama had to be sure. So he turned to Yudhisthira, the eldest of the Pandava brothers, who always spoke the truth since he was the son of Dharma . Over the din of the battlefield, Yudhisthira replied Yes. Ashwathama, the elephant, is dead. But while enunciating the elephant, Yudhisthira deliberately lowered his volume a little so that he would not be heard. Bheeshmapitama was immediately stunned by the news of his sons death. Seizing the opportunity, the Pandavas felled him with a thousand arrows.
Had he not been slain, the Pandavas would have been defeated right in the early stages of the battle. They used subtle deception to avoid certain defeat at the hands of their malicious brethren. Clearly, deception was justified here.
上一篇: SAT写作开头范文两例
下一篇: SAT写作素材之Plato
高考英语作文素材: 博学的教授 Learned Professor
2017届高考英语听力素材:诗歌篇 14-The Furthest Distance in the World
高考英语作文素材: 大款征婚 亦真亦幻 Multimillionaire Seeks Wife
高考英语一轮单元总复习 Module 3《Interpersonal Relationships—Friendship》教案 外研版选修6
高考英语作文素材:电子游戏危害谈(Harmfulness of Video Games)作文素材
2017届高考英语听力素材:诗歌篇 18-You Know My Heart
2017届高考英语听力素材:诗歌篇 15-Ode to the Oak
高考英语一轮单元总复习 Module 2《The Renaissance》教案 外研版选修8
高考英语作文素材: 订婚仪式作文素材
我的校园 My School
高考英语一轮单元总复习 Module 5《Cloning》教案 外研版选修6
2017届高考英语听力素材:诗歌篇 07-Paradise Lost
美国官员:俄罗斯违反导弹条约
高考英语一轮单元总复习 Module 4《Which English》教案 外研版选修8
高考英语作文素材:鼓浪屿—人间仙境(Gulangyu
高考英语作文素材: 财富与人生 Wealth and Life
高考英语作文素材: 不要指望经济困境迅速缓解 No Easy Fix for Economy
2017届高考英语听力素材:诗歌篇 13-I’ve Been Working on the Railroad
高考英语作文素材: 穿校服的利与弊 Advantages and Disadvantages of Wearing school uniforms
2017届高考英语听力素材:生活篇 1.2.1 提议同逛街
高考英语作文素材: 城市生活与效区生活 City Life and Suburban Life
高考英语作文素材:东方明珠电视塔(The Oriental Pearl TV Tower)作文素材
2017届高考英语听力素材:诗歌篇 16-The Passionate Shepherd to His Love
高考英语一轮单元总复习 Module 5《The Conquest of the Universe》教案 外研版选修8
高考英语一轮单元总复习 Module 5《 A Trip Along the Three Gorges》教案 外研版必修4
2017届高考英语听力素材:生活篇 1.2.2 购买家具
2017届高考英语听力素材:生活篇 1.7.3 取包裹
高考英语作文素材:电视和电影的影响(The Influence of Television and Movies)作文素材
2017年校园足球计划公布 将建成2万所足球特色学校
高考英语一轮单元总复习 Module 1《Small Talk》教案 外研版选修6