87. The following appeared in an ad for a book titled How to Write a Screenplay for a Movie.
Writers who want to succeed should try to write film screenplays rather than books, since the average film tends to make greater profits than does even a best-selling book. It is true that some books are also made into films. However, our nations film producers are more likely to produce movies based on original screenplays than to produce films based on books, because in recent years the films that have sold the most tickets have usually been based on original screenplays.
Discuss how well reasoned... etc.
This advertisement for How to Write a Screenplay... concludes that a writer is more likely to be successful by writing original screenplays than by writing books. The ads reasoning is based on two claims: the average film tends to be more profitable than even best-selling books, and film producers are more likely to make movies based on original screenplays than on books because in recent years the films that have sold the most tickets have usually been based on original screenplays. I find the ad unconvincing, on three grounds.
First, the mere fact that ticket sales in recent years for screenplay-based movies have exceeded those for book-based movies is insufficient evidence to conclude that writing screenplays now provides greater financial opportunity for writers. Ticket-sale statistics from only a few recent years are not necessarily a good indicator of future trends. It is possible that fees paid by movie studios for screenplays might decrease in the future relative to those for book rights. Moreover, the argument is based on number of ticket sales, not on movie-studio profits or writers fees. It is possible that studio profits and writer fees have actually been greater recently for book-based movies than for those based on original screenplays.
Another problem with the ad is that it assumes a writer must make an either-or choice from the outset between writing books and writing screenplays. The argument fails to rule out the possibility that a writer engage in both types of writing as well as other types. In fact a writer may be more successful by doing so. Writing in various genres might improve ones effectiveness in each of them. Also, writing a book may be an effective first step to producing a screenplay. In any event, the ad provides no justification for the mutually exclusive choice it imposes on the writer.
A third problem with the ad is its ambiguous use of the word successful. The argument simply equates success with movie ticket sales. However, many writers may define writing success in other terms, such as intellectual or artistic fulfillment. The ads advice that writing screenplays is the best way to achieve writing success ignores other definitions of success.
In conclusion, this quick pitch for a book is based on simplistic assumptions about ticket sales and writer fees, and on an overly narrow definition of success in writing. To better evaluate this argument, at the very least we would need to know the number of years the cited statistic was based on, and the extent to which ticket sales reflect movie studio profits and writer fees.
上一篇: GMAT考试之Kaplan写作策略
下一篇: GMAT考试写作例文224篇连载(三三)
2014届高三英语一轮单元复习训练:Module 1 Basketball(外研版选修7)
2014届高三英语一轮单元复习训练:Module 3 Literature(外研版选修7)
2014年高考英语复习资料大全40
2014届高三英语一轮单元复习训练:Module 1 My First Day at Senior High外研版必修1
2014年高考英语复习资料大全29
2014届高三英语一轮单元复习训练:Module 4 Fine Arts—Western,Chinese and Pop Arts(外研版必修2)
2014年高考英语复习资料大全46
2014年高考英语复习资料大全28
2014年高考英语复习资料大全26
2014年高考英语复习资料大全33
2014届高三英语一轮单元复习训练:Module 2 Fantasy Literature—Philip Pullman(外研版选修6)
2014届高三英语一轮单元复习训练:Module 2 Highlights of My Senior Year(外研版选修7)
2014届高三英语一轮单元复习训练:Module 3 Adventure in Literature and the Cinema(外研版必修5)
2014届高三英语一轮单元复习训练:Module 4 Music Born in America(外研版选修7)
2014届高三英语一轮单元复习训练:Module 2 No Drugs(外研版必修2)
2014年高考英语复习资料大全48
2014年高考英语复习资料大全24
2014年高考英语复习资料大全34
2014年高考英语复习资料大全42
2014年高考英语复习资料大全43
2014年高考英语复习资料大全27
2014年高考英语复习资料大全47
2014届高三英语一轮单元复习训练:Module 1 British and American English(外研版必修5)
2014届高三英语一轮单元复习训练:Module 2 A Job Worth Doing(外研版必修5)
2014年高考英语复习资料大全32
2014届高三英语一轮单元复习训练:Module 1 Our Body and Healthy Habits(外研版必修2)
2014年高考英语复习资料大全50
2014届高三英语一轮单元复习训练:Module 2 My New Teachers外研版必修1
2014年高考英语复习资料大全31
2014年高考英语复习资料大全39