34. The potential benefits of mandatory public service must be weighed against
administrative problems and concerns about individual liberty. On balance, the costs to
a nation and to the participants would probably exceed the benefits.
Admittedly, a colorable argument can be made for mandatory public service. It
would help alleviate free-rider problems, where those who do not contribute benefit
from the efforts of those who do. It would mitigate pressing social problems―with
education, public health and safety, and the environment. It might instill in participants a
sense of civic duty, community, and individual responsibility. Finally, it has worked on a
smaller scale, particularly in urban areas, where renewal projects succeed in making
communities safer, healthier, and more prosperous.
Far more compelling, however, are the arguments against mandatory public
service. First, who would make assignments and decide what projects are worthwhile,
and how would compliance be assured? Resolving enforcement issues would require
government control, in turn requiring increased taxes and/or cuts in other social
programs, thereby nullifying the benefits of mandatory public service. Second, a
mandatory system would open the floodgates to incompetence and inexperience. Finally,
the whole notion seems tantamount to Communism insofar as each citizen must
contribute, according to his or her ability, to a strong state. Modern history informs us
that such systems do not work. One could argue that mandatory public service is simply
a tax in the form of labor rather than dollars. However, compulsory labor smacks of
involuntary servitude, whereas financial taxes do not.
In conclusion, logistical and philosophical barriers to mandating public service
outweigh its potential benefits for the nation as well as for participants.
上一篇: GMAT写作模板:少数和多数
下一篇: GMAT写作范文:理想与现实
2017届高考英语一轮复习基础提升晨练:Module 1《British and American English》(外研版必修5)
2017届高考英语一轮复习基础提升晨练:Module 1《Europe》(外研版必修3)
2017届高三英语一轮检测题:必修4(北师大版)
2017届高考英语一轮复习基础提升晨练:Module 2《Fantasy Literature—Philip Pullman》(外研版选修6)
2017届四川省高考英语完形填空训练(3)
2017届浙江省高考英语单项选择暑假练习(1)
2017届高考英语一轮复习基础提升晨练:Module 1《Deep South》(外研版选修8)
2017届浙江省高考英语一轮阅读理解训练(7)
2017届高考英语一轮复习基础提升晨练:Module 1《Our Body and Healthy Habits》(外研版必修2)
2017届高考英语一轮复习基础提升晨练:Module 2《Highlights of My Senior Year》(外研版选修7)
2017届高考英语一轮复习基础提升晨练:Module 1《My First Day at Senior High》(外研版必修1)
2017届浙江省高考英语一轮阅读理解训练(3)
2017届四川省高考英语完形填空训练(1)
2017届浙江省高考英语阅读理解暑假练习(3)
2017届高考英语一轮复习基础提升晨练:Module 2《Traffic Jam》(外研版必修4)
2017届高考英语一轮复习基础提升晨练:Module 3《Interpersonal Relationships Friendship》(外研版选修6)
2017届浙江省高考英语阅读理解暑假练习(1)
2017届四川省高考英语完形填空训练(2)
2017届高考英语一轮复习基础提升晨练:Module 2《The Renaissance》(外研版选修8)
2017届浙江省高考英语一轮阅读理解训练(4)
2017届高三英语一轮检测题:选修8(北师大版)
2017届四川省高考英语完形填空训练(5)
2017届四川省高考英语完形填空训练(6)
2017届高考英语一轮复习基础提升晨练:Module 3《Body Language and Non-verbal Communication》(外研版必修4)
2017届高三英语一轮检测题:必修3(北师大版)
2017届浙江省高考英语阅读理解暑假练习(5)
2017届浙江省高考英语一轮阅读理解训练(2)
2017届高考英语一轮复习基础提升晨练:Module 3《Music》(外研版必修2)
2017届浙江省高考英语单项选择暑假练习(3)
2017届高三英语一轮检测题:必修1(北师大版)