42. The speaker argues that because scientists continually shift viewpoints about how
our actions affect the natural environment, companies should not change their products
and processes according to scientific recommendations until the government requires
them to do so. This argument raises complex issues about the duties of business and
about regulatory fairness and effectiveness. Although a wait-and-see policy may help
companies avoid costly and unnecessary changes, three countervailing considerations
compel me to disagree overall with the argument.
First, a regulatory system of environmental protection might not operate equitably.
At first glance, a wait-and-see response might seem fair in that all companies would be
subject to the same standards and same enforcement measures. However, enforcement
requires detection, and while some violators may be caught, others might not. Moreover,
a broad regulatory system imposes general standards that may not apply equitably to
every company. Suppose, for example, that pollution from a company in a valley does
more damage to the environment than similar pollution from a company on the coast. It
would seem unfair to require the coastal company to invest as heavily in abatement or,
in the extreme, to shut down the operation if the company cannot afford abatement
measures.
Secondly, the argument assumes that the government regulations will properly
reflect scientific recommendations. However, this claim is somewhat dubious.
Companies with the most money and political influence, not the scientists, might in
some cases dictate regulatory standards. In other words, legislators may be more
influenced by political expediency and campaign pork than by societal concerns.
Thirdly, waiting until government regulations are in place can have disastrous
effects on the environment. A great deal of environmental damage can occur before
regulations are implemented. This problem is compounded whenever government
reaction to scientific evidence is slow. Moreover, the EPA might be overburdened with
its detection and enforcement duties, thereby allowing continued environmental damage
by companies who have not yet been caught or who appeal penalties.
In conclusion, despite uncertainty within the scientific community about what
environmental standards are best, companies should not wait for government regulation
before reacting to warnings about environmental problems. The speakers recommended
approach would in many cases operate inequitably among companies: moreover, it
ignores the political-corruption factor as well as the potential environmental damage
resulting from bureaucratic delay.
下一篇: GMAT新黄金80题及范文(十九)
国内英语资讯:China offers help to 150 countries, 4 intl organizations to fight COVID-19: white paper
体坛英语资讯:Polish football league to restart on May 29
自画像
国际英语资讯:Spotlight: Syrians complain of skyrocketing prices amid tough economic situation
国际英语资讯:Palestine slams Israel for deportation of worshippers from Al-Aqsa Mosque
放花炮
文具盒
体坛英语资讯:Italian Serie A to resume in early August
国际英语资讯:2 officers in New York state charged with felony assault after shoving elderly protester
国际英语资讯:Italys COVID-19 death toll rises by 72 to 33,846
老外说January and May,千万不要理解成一月和五月
国内英语资讯:China publishes white paper on fight against COVID-19
体坛英语资讯:Zganjer, Usnik appointed assistant coaches of Iran
每日一词∣国家级经济技术开发区 state
国内英语资讯:Chinese vice premier stresses smooth transition from anti-poverty fight to rural vitalizatio
国际英语资讯:U.S. welcomes Egyptian initiative for political settlement in Libya
体坛英语资讯:Iran remains sixth in global futsal ranking
压腿
变成小星星
国内英语资讯:Liaison office of Chinese central govt in HKSAR holds symposium on national security legis
看夜色
美翻!《航拍中国》第三季,从高空俯瞰这江山如画
体坛英语资讯:Portugal launches measures to maintain sports
我的梦想
国际英语资讯:Trump orders withdrawal of National Guard from Washington, D.C.
中新“快捷通道”今日开启
国际英语资讯:Protests spread across Germany over George Floyd killing in U.S.
国内英语资讯:Central SOEs to invest heavily in virus-hit Hubei
国际英语资讯:India govt strives to generate employment for migrant labourers at their doorsteps
国际英语资讯:U.S. COVID-19 deaths top 110,000 -- Johns Hopkins University