analysis of argument 1
the following appeared as part of an annual report sent to stockholders by olympic foods, a processor of frozen foods.
over time, the costs of processing go down BECause as organizations learn how to do things better, they become more efficient. in color film processing, for example, the cost of a 3-by-5-inch print fell from 50 cents for five-day service in 1970 to 20 cents for one-day service in 1984. the same principle applies to the processing of food. and since olympic foods will soon celebrate its twenty-fifth birthday, we can expect that our long experience will enable us to minimize costs and thus maximize profits.
answer
the author argues, using facts from the color-film processing industrys downward trend in cost over 24 years, that olympic foods will be able to cut costs and thus maximize profits in the future. the author bases his conclusion on the generalization that organizations learn to reduce costs over time and, since olympic foods has 25 years experience in the food processing industry, its costs should have declined considerably. there are two serious flaws in the argument.
first, the argument uses a faulty analogy between the color-film processing industry and the food processing industry. analogies drawn between the two fields are highly suspect because there are many serious differences. while the film processing industry faces a relatively simply processing challenge, food producers must contend with contamination, transportation and farm production . thus, it is likely much more difficult to wring efficiency improvements in the food industry.
second, the author uses a sweeping generalization. the authors prediction of margin improvements relies on the optimistic assumption that olympic foods 25 years of experience will automatically result in operational efficiencies. the problem with this is that improvements in processes do not occur automatically over time, they require tremendous effort at continuous improvement and they require potential room for improvement. it is possible olympic food has limited room for improvement or lacks the managerial will to improve its operations. thus, there is no guarantee of improved operational efficiency over time.
the authors argument has two seriously flawed assumptions. the author could strengthen his conclusion by providing examples of how the company has learned how to improve its operations over 25 years and implemented those changes.
上一篇: GMAT issue提纲(十三)
下一篇: GMAT作文范文:不同领域间的交流2
国内英语资讯:Second Sino-German economic dialogue kicks off in Berlin
Iverson, Carmelo power Nuggets by Spurs
棒球联盟得到日本的帮助 Baseball league gets Japanese help
Figure skating champions to tie knot
China piles up more diving gold medals
Brazilian player booked for kissing ref
Yao helps Rockets overcome Lakers
Mavs keep cool, tie series with Warriors
Rockets hang on to beat visiting Pistons
Zheng to return to Shandong for East Asian tournament
Meet China prospect Yi at NBA
易建联准备开始NBA之旅Yi ready to live American Dream
阿里那斯膝伤将缺阵2-3个月 Arenas out 2-3 months with knee injury
Ohio States Oden plans to enter draft
Australia outmuscle China 2-0 at friendly
Bosh helps Raptors top Nets, even series
不再有贝克汉姆,但皇马却赢了 No Beckham again, but Real Madrid wins
从姚明到易建联
Bayi wins CBA title after beating Guangdong 88-83
Beckham wins Sport Industry award
教练:陈宏的回归对中国是个坏消息
中国在亚洲锦标赛中获得三枚金牌
利物浦,AC米兰晋级半决赛
苏丹政府被控在达尔富尔使用化学武器
国内英语资讯:Chinese presidents special envoy attends Peres funeral
Rooney strikes as Man United go six points clear
Yao no longer NBAs big man in China as Kobe rules
NBA stopover adds to Shanghai credentials
Du Li shoots down a gold in ISSF World Cup
贝克汉姆准备开战皇家马德里