The following appeared as part of an article in a popular arts and leisure magazine.
The safety codes governing the construction of public buildings are becoming far too strict. The surest way for architects and builders to prove that they have met the minimum requirements established by these codes is to construct buildings by using the same materials and methods that are currently allowed. But doing so means that there will be very little significant technological innovation within the industry, and hence little evolution of architectural styles and designmerely because of the strictness of these safety codes.
Discuss how well reasoned... etc.
The conclusion of this argument is that technological innovation as well as the evolution of architectural styles and design will be minimized in the future. The authors line of reasoning is that the imposition of strict safety codes on public buildings inhibits the evolution of architectural styles and design, because they discourage technological innovation within the building industry. Furthermore, the strictness of the codes governing public buildings discourages technological innovation because the surest way for architects and builders to pass the codes is to construct buildings that use the same materials and methods that are currently allowed. This argument is unconvincing for two reasons.
In the first place, the authors conclusion goes beyond the evidence presented. The evidence cited pertains only to the construction of public buildings, yet the author draws a conclusion about the building industry as a whole. Technological innovation and architectural experimentation in style and design in the construction of private buildings is not precluded by the reasons cited. Consequently, in the absence of evidence that similar problems beset the construction of privately owned buildings, the authors conclusion is not warranted.
In the second place, it is not evident that the strict safety codes governing public buildings will have the effects predicted by the author. Architectural styles and design are not dictated solely by the materials or the methods employed in construction. Consequently, it is premature to conclude that little evolution in style and design will occur because the materials and methods will likely remain the same. Moreover, technological innovation is not restricted to the use of new materials and methods. Significant technological innovation can be achieved by applying existing methods to new situations and by finding new uses for familiar materials.
In conclusion, the author has failed to make the case for the claim that technological innovation as well as the evolution of architectural styles and design will be minimized in the future. To strengthen the argument the author would have to show that similar safety code restrictions impede the evolution of the design and the innovation of new technologies in the construction of private buildings. Additionally, the author must show that materials and methods are the prime determinants of architectural style and design.
上一篇: 精选GMAT写作范文50篇(38)
下一篇: 精选GMAT写作范文50篇(32)
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块六《Unit 4 Helping people around the world》(学生版) 牛津译林版
2016届高考英语二轮语法强化训练27 主谓一致
2016年高考英语:备考之百题精炼系列08(教师版)
2016届高考英语二轮语法强化训练20 名词
2016年高考英语:备考百题精炼专题1(教师版)
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块六《Unit 2 What is happiness to you》(学生版) 牛津译林版
2016届高考英语二轮语法强化训练15 形容词
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块七《Unit 1 Living with Technology》(学生版) 牛津译林版
2016年高考英语:备考之百题精炼系列09(教师版)
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块六《Unit 4 Helping people around the world》(教师版) 牛津译林版
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块三《Unit 2 Language》(学生版) 牛津译林版
2016年高考英语:备考之百题精炼系列02(教师版)
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块七《Unit 3 The world on line》(学生版) 牛津译林版
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块六《Unit 1 Laughter is good for you》(学生版) 牛津译林版
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块二《Unit 3 Amazing people》(学生版) 牛津译林版
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块七《Unit 1 Living with Technology》(教师版) 牛津译林版
2016届高考英语二轮语法强化训练26 时态和语态
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块二《Unit 3 Amazing people》(教师版) 牛津译林版
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块七《Unit 2 Fit for life》(教师版) 牛津译林版
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块七《Unit 4 Public transportation》(学生版) 牛津译林版
2016届高考英语二轮语法强化训练17 副词
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块三《Unit 1 The world of our senses》(学生版) 牛津译林版
2016年高考英语:备考之百题精炼系列06(教师版)
2016届高考英语二轮语法强化训练30 省略句
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块六《Unit 1 Laughter is good for you》(教师版) 牛津译林版
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块七《Unit 3 The world on line》(教师版) 牛津译林版
2016届高考英语二轮语法强化训练28 强调句
Sharing waste food and steepest street 剩余食材再利用、最陡的街道
2016年高考英语配套词汇检测训练:模块六《Unit 3 Understanding each other》(教师版) 牛津译林版
2016届高考英语二轮语法强化训练19 名词